review-22-skill-router

Route, merge, and validate review-writing skills for a medical literature review workbench. Use when the user asks to combine local review skills, Nature/Science-style skills, GitHub skill repositorie

SKILL.md

GitHub

Review Skill Router

Use this skill after the core review pipeline exists and the user wants to add, compare, or reuse other skill systems. The goal is not to copy every external skill into the workbench. The goal is to decide which external skill should inform which review step, keep the original source visible, and avoid importing unverified or incompatible instructions.

Routing Rules

  1. Start from the current review step, not from the external skill name.
  2. Prefer the local review-00 to review-28 skills for the main workflow.
  3. Use external skills as reference layers:
    • Nature or Science style: argument architecture, figure standards, citation discipline, editorial polish.
    • PRISMA/systematic review: protocol, search, screening, reporting checklist, flow diagram.
    • Academic research suites: research planning, literature synthesis, writing, review, revision.
    • Scientific agent skills: database access, citation verification, biomedical workflows, reproducible outputs.
  4. Never treat a GitHub skill as authoritative medical evidence. It can guide process, not replace PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, Cochrane, guidelines, or primary literature.
  5. Check license/source notes before copying content. If unsure, summarize the workflow pattern and link the source instead of copying the text.
  6. Every routed decision must leave a small artifact in 19_skill_library or the relevant step folder.

Decision Workflow

  1. Identify the user's task type: six-step workbench setup, topic design, search, screening, full-text reading, Zotero/PDF handoff, evidence matrix, section-chain writing, manuscript drafting, figures/tables, GitHub archive, citation audit, journal match, submission, response, or final QC.
  2. Map the task to the native review skill.
  3. Select at most three external references that add value for that step.
  4. State what is adopted, what is rejected, and why.
  5. Write the result into the workbench using the existing folder structure.
  6. If the task affects medical claims, add an evidence-boundary reminder.

Default Routing Map

Task Native skill External references to consider Guardrail
Review protocol or PICO/PECO/PCC review-01, review-02 PRISMA, academic research suite Do not finalize until scope and population are explicit
Six-step public workflow or course demo review-28 GitHub skills, Nature skills, academic skills, Xiaohongshu/video workflows Compress long workflow into six auditable steps; plugins optional
Search strategy review-03, review-04 systematic literature review skills, biomedical database skills Record database, date, full string, and result count
Screening and PRISMA review-08 PRISMA-focused skills Keep exclusion reasons auditable
Benchmark review reading review-07, review-10 Nature reader, academic paper reviewer Separate article structure learning from evidence extraction
Evidence matrix review-11 citation verifier, scientific agent skills No claim without source, DOI/PMID, and evidence level
Reference search and insertion review-23 academic MCP search, Nature citation, citation verifier Recent high-quality DOI/PMID references only; avoid user-excluded journals
Section-chain writing review-24 Nature writing, academic writing, manuscript optimizer Advance one manuscript stage at a time; stop if evidence is missing
Zotero and PDF handoff review-25 Zotero MCP, PubMed export, fulltext retrieval tools Search hits are not usable evidence until PDF/full-text status is known
Outline and manuscript review-12 to review-16 Nature writing, scientific writing, manuscript optimizer Improve logic and style without adding unsupported mechanisms
Figures and tables review-13, review-26 Nature figure, Figma, BioRender, SVG, Excel Track source, permission, caption, and manuscript callout
GitHub archive and versioning review-27 GitHub workflow, project templates, reproducibility notes Do not publish PDFs, patient data, licensed assets, or active drafts publicly
Citation audit review-17 citation verifier, Nature citation, review-23 outputs Verify every key citation against source text
Journal and submission review-18, review-19 Nature portfolio playbook, submission audit Match article type, scope, limits, fees, and policies
Revision response review-20 rebuttal response, peer review Respond point by point and cite revised locations
Final QC review-21 all relevant external checks Evidence, numbers, causality, ethics, declarations, and journal fit must pass

Reference Files

Read references/mainstream-skill-index.md when the user asks what external or mainstream skills are available.

Read references/review-skill-routing.md when selecting which external skill layer to combine with a specific review step.

When the local 490 SCI review package is present (00-SCI综述专家 to 20-审稿人意见回复器), do not treat it as a generic external reference by default. Read references/490-sci-workflow-integration.md and apply the best-of-both routing: native review-* skills keep medical evidence gates and final audit, while stronger 490 modules may become execution submodules for search export, Zotero/PDF handling, benchmark learning, target-journal learning, permissions, cover letter, submission guidance, and reviewer response.

Required Output

When this skill is used, return or update:

  • A routing decision: current step, native skill, external skills considered, selected references.
  • A merge decision: what is adopted, what is only noted, what is rejected.
  • A validation note: what artifact proves this step is complete.
  • A source note for any GitHub or external repository referenced.