review-20-reviewer-response

Draft structured reviewer responses and revision plans for medical review manuscripts. Use after peer-review comments, editorial decisions, or pre-submission internal review.

SKILL.md

GitHub

Review 20 Reviewer Response

Purpose

Convert reviewer comments into a polite, specific, evidence-supported response and manuscript revision plan.

Required Inputs

  • Reviewer/editor comments.
  • Current manuscript version.
  • Files changed or planned changes.
  • Evidence matrix and citation audit if claims are challenged.

Output

Create files under 16_revision_response/:

  • comment_response_table.md.
  • revision_plan.md.
  • tracked_change_summary.md.
  • additional_evidence_needed.md.

Completion Gate

Pass only when every comment has a response, action, manuscript location, and evidence support if needed.

Stop Rules

Do not promise experiments, analyses, or data that the user has not provided or approved.