review-10-deep-reading

Produce structured deep-reading notes from full-text medical papers. Use when extracting methods, results, mechanisms, limitations, and usable review material from PDFs.

SKILL.md

GitHub

Review 10 Deep Reading

Purpose

Extract evidence in a way that preserves the boundary between reported findings and interpretation.

Required Inputs

  • Full-text PDFs or readable text.
  • Classification table.
  • Review question and target themes.

Output

Create one note per paper under 07_reading_notes/paper_notes/ with:

  • Citation and study type.
  • Objective and design.
  • Population/model/sample.
  • Key findings with page/table/figure location.
  • Limitations.
  • Usable manuscript point.
  • Do-not-overstate warning.

Completion Gate

Pass only when key claims include source location and evidence strength.

Stop Rules

Do not convert association into mechanism or causality unless the original paper supports it experimentally.