review-06-gap-topic

Identify candidate research gaps and refine review angle from retrieved literature. Use after pilot search or initial screening to compare existing reviews, map gaps, and choose a defensible topic.

SKILL.md

GitHub

Review 06 Gap Topic

Purpose

Convert search evidence into a defensible review angle without overstating novelty.

Required Inputs

  • Search results or exported citation list.
  • Existing reviews on the topic.
  • Project question and target audience.

Output

Create 01_question_scope/gap_topic_report.md with:

  • Existing review landscape.
  • Candidate gaps with supporting papers.
  • Risk of duplication.
  • Recommended angle and title.
  • Terms that must be avoided because evidence is insufficient.

Completion Gate

Pass only when each proposed gap is linked to actual retrieved literature or explicitly marked as unverified.

Stop Rules

Do not write "first", "novel", or "comprehensive" unless verified by a documented search.