review-00-controller

Orchestrate a stepwise SCI/narrative/systematic review workbench. Use when the user wants to start, resume, audit, or verify a medical literature review workflow with gated steps, deliverables, and ne

SKILL.md

GitHub

Review 00 Controller

Purpose

Act as the master controller for a medical review project. Do not write manuscript content unless the relevant upstream evidence files exist. Route the user to the next numbered review skill only after the previous step has a concrete deliverable.

Workflow

  1. Identify the current project folder, review type, topic, target journal if known, and latest completed checkpoint.
  2. Inspect the project-level 项目看板.md and the folder for the active stage. In the standard six-step template, these are 01_选题_期刊_框架, 02_文献_Zotero_PDF, 03_正文撰写_框架填充, 04_图表制作_素材管理, 05_投稿材料_终审, and 06_返修回复_再投稿.
  3. Classify status as not_started, in_progress, blocked, or passed.
  4. State the missing files or decisions before proceeding.
  5. Recommend the next skill by exact name, for example $review-03-search-string.
  6. Before submission or major revision, route to $review-21-personal-qc even if $review-20-reviewer-response is not needed.

If the user asks for a simplified six-step course/demo workflow, a no-plugin workflow, or a "six steps to complete a review" explanation, route to $review-28-six-step-workbench first.

Completion Gate

The step may pass only when:

  • The previous step has a dated output file.
  • The file contains source information or an explicit "not yet available" note.
  • Human decisions are recorded when choices are required.
  • Claims are not presented as evidence unless linked to a paper, dataset, or user-provided material.

Output

Return a short progress note with:

  • Current stage.
  • Files checked.
  • Pass/fail decision.
  • Next action and next skill.

Stop Rules

Stop and ask for user input if the research question, disease/domain, review type, or target journal constraints are absent and cannot be inferred from existing project files.

Personal Workflow Memory

When the user asks to improve the workbench or distill their own writing process, read references/personal-review-workflow.md if present and use it to update checklists, gates, and final-audit logic.