goal-achievement-review

Goal achievement verification methodology. Truths, artifacts, and key links verification for reviewer agent.

SKILL.md

GitHub

Usage

Loaded automatically when its description matches the active task. The body below provides the working context.

Goal Achievement Review

Truths Verification

For each truth from must_haves:

  • TRUE: confirmed by code (file exists, logic is correct)
  • FALSE: truth not achieved → P0 blocker
  • PARTIAL: partially implemented → P1 warning

Artifacts Verification

For each artifact, 3 levels:

  • Level 1: File exists?
  • Level 2: File is not a stub (real code, not placeholder)?
  • Level 3: File exports/contains what was declared?

Key Links Verification

For each key_link:

  • Is there a real connection from → to?
  • Is the via method used?
# Example key_link check
grep -l "fetch.*api/chat" src/components/Chat.tsx  # from → to via fetch

Output Format

## Goal Achievement
| Truth | Status | Evidence |
|-------|--------|----------|
| "Shortcodes are replaced" | TRUE | parser.ts:45 parseShortcodes() |
| "Non-existent don't break" | PARTIAL | no fallback for unknown |