paired-council

Use when deliberating on strategic questions, brainstorming, or making decisions that benefit from multiple behavioral perspectives in productive tension. Deploys math-optimized persona pairs (from so

SKILL.md

GitHub

Paired Council

Deploys math-optimized persona pairs from the sovereign balance matrix to deliberate on a question. Each pair debates internally, producing productive tension that individual personas cannot. The pair format catches blind spots that single-perspective councils miss.

Commands

Command Default Pairs Purpose
/paired-council deliberate <question> Auto-select by query type Strategic deliberation
/paired-council brainstorm <topic> Innovation-weighted pairs Creative exploration
/paired-council audit <concern> Safety-weighted pairs Risk assessment
/paired-council custom <pair1,pair2,...> <question> User-specified Custom pair selection

Math-Optimized Pairs (from sovereign balance rankings)

Combo Name Pair Balance Energy Best For
Mirror Match Maverick + Specialist 0.87 31 Innovation + verification. Bold moves stress-tested.
Knowledge Bomb Analyzer + Persuader 0.50 23 Research → weapon. Evidence packaged for impact.
The Humanitarian Altruist + Controller 0.50 25 Human cost + accountability. Ethics meets operations.
The Bridge Collaborator + Controller 0.87 21 Relationship dynamics. Softens rigid systems.
Controlled Burn Maverick + Guardian 1.50 27 Bold with a firewall. Speed checked by safety.
Recon Analyzer + Adapter 3.08 15 Scout + staging. Prep work and terrain mapping.

Auto-Selection Logic

digraph pair_selection {
  "Query type?" [shape=diamond];
  "Strategic/vision" [shape=box, label="Mirror Match + Knowledge Bomb\n+ The Humanitarian + The Bridge"];
  "Technical/build" [shape=box, label="Mirror Match + Controlled Burn\n+ Knowledge Bomb + Recon"];
  "People/culture" [shape=box, label="The Humanitarian + The Bridge\n+ Knowledge Bomb"];
  "Risk/safety" [shape=box, label="Controlled Burn + The Bridge\n+ Knowledge Bomb + Recon"];
  "Brainstorm" [shape=box, label="Mirror Match + Knowledge Bomb\n+ The Humanitarian"];

  "Query type?" -> "Strategic/vision" [label="strategy"];
  "Query type?" -> "Technical/build" [label="build"];
  "Query type?" -> "People/culture" [label="people"];
  "Query type?" -> "Risk/safety" [label="risk"];
  "Query type?" -> "Brainstorm" [label="creative"];
}

Execution Protocol

Step 1: Parse Command

Extract query, pair selection (auto or custom), scope.

Step 2: Fetch Context

  • Repo relays: GET http://localhost:8100/constellation/relays/repos
  • Persona relays: GET http://localhost:8100/constellation/relays/personas
  • Read relevant profile YAMLs from airlock-persona/profiles/

Step 3: Select Pairs

Use auto-selection logic or user-specified pairs. Default: 3-4 pairs.

Step 4: Write Briefing

~200 token briefing with: query, scope, key facts from relays, current context.

Step 5: Dispatch Pairs (Parallel)

For each pair, dispatch ONE subagent that simulates BOTH personas in dialogue. Use model: "sonnet" for cost efficiency.

IMPORTANT: Dispatch ALL pair subagents in a SINGLE message (parallel execution).

Each subagent receives the paired-council-prompt.md template:

You are simulating a PAIRED DISCUSSION between two Otto personas.

## The Pair: {COMBO_NAME} ({PERSONA_A} + {PERSONA_B})
- **{PERSONA_A}** (D:{D}, E:{E}, P:{P}, F:{F}) — {BIO}
- **{PERSONA_B}** (D:{D}, E:{E}, P:{P}, F:{F}) — {BIO}
- **Pair Math:** Balance {BALANCE}, Energy {ENERGY}. {PAIR_DESCRIPTION}

## The Question
{BRIEFING + QUERY}

## Format
Simulate the actual discussion. Show productive tension. Then deliver joint verdict.

{PERSONA_A}: [speaks first — in character]
{PERSONA_B}: [responds — in character, catches what A missed]
{PERSONA_A}: [reacts, pushes back or agrees]
{PERSONA_B}: [final word]

{COMBO_NAME} VERDICT:
- The thing we found: [one clear statement]
- Why it matters: [2-3 sentences]
- Recommended action: [specific, actionable]
- Conviction: [0-10]

Step 6: Collect Verdicts

Parse each pair's verdict. Extract: finding, reasoning, action, conviction.

Step 7: Guardian Gate

Scan all verdicts for safety/sustainability/alignment risks. If any concern has conviction >= 7.5, flag as HARD_DISAGREE. If no Guardian persona in pair set, Knowledge Bomb or Controlled Burn serves as proxy gate.

Step 8: Captain Synthesis

As Captain, synthesize:

  • Where pairs converge (consensus)
  • Where pairs diverge (productive disagreement)
  • Sequenced recommended actions
  • Decision status: INFORMATIONAL, AWAITING_ZAC, or BLOCKED

Step 9: Persist Report

Write YAML report to ~/Desktop/Airlock/repos/airlock-coordination/reports/ Follow schema. Prepend to INDEX.yaml. Include format: paired_council and pairs: metadata.

Privacy rule: request_summary is SYNTHESIZED, never verbatim.

Step 10: Render Report

══════════════════════════════════════════════════
  PAIRED COUNCIL REPORT
  Type: {command} | Query: "{query}"
  Date: {date} | Pairs: {count}
══════════════════════════════════════════════════

{For each pair:}
──────────────────────────────────────────────────
{COMBO_NAME} ({PERSONA_A} + {PERSONA_B}) — Balance {N}, Energy {N}
Conviction: {N}

[Abbreviated discussion highlights]

Verdict: {finding}
Action: {recommendation}
──────────────────────────────────────────────────

══════════════════════════════════════════════════
  CONSENSUS
  Avg Conviction: {N} | Agreement: {X}/{Y}
  GUARDIAN GATE: {PASS|HARD_DISAGREE}
══════════════════════════════════════════════════

CAPTAIN SYNTHESIS
{synthesis with sequenced actions}

Decision Status: {status}
══════════════════════════════════════════════════

Why Pairs Beat Individuals

Individual Council Paired Council
Each persona gives isolated take Each pair produces internal debate
No productive tension within response Behavioral mirrors generate tension
Blind spots remain per-persona Pair's opposite drives catch blind spots
Generic agreement patterns Math-validated complementary perspectives
N perspectives, N responses N/2 pairs, each with internal dialogue

Cost

  • 3-4 pairs × Sonnet = $0.15-0.30 per council
  • ~30 seconds parallel execution
  • Significantly richer output than individual councils at similar cost