moat-analysis
Use this skill to evaluate economic moat sources, durability, evidence, competitive advantages, switching costs, scale economies, network effects, brand, regulation, or cost advantages. Trigger when b
SKILL.mdskills/moat-analysis/SKILL.md
GitHubMoat Analysis Skill
Purpose
Assess the depth, durability, and competitive threats of an economic moat with auditable evidence. For L1+ public-company analysis, include compact quantitative moat checks when data is available; for quick checks, private companies, early-stage loss makers, or non-comparable assets, state what is blocked or deferred.
Applicability and Depth
Use the smallest useful moat packet:
| Analysis depth | Required treatment |
|---|---|
| L0 quick check | 1-2 sentence moat view; flag missing data |
| L1 standard report | Compact moat table with ROIC spread, inferred moat category, trend, and key threat |
| L2+ full memo | Full multi-method assessment, peer benchmark, and evidence trail |
| Data-blocked / not comparable | Mark as blocked, low-confidence, or not applicable; do not invent scores |
Combined Moat Evidence Framework
1. ROIC Spread / AFOS Test
ROIC Spread = ROIC - WACC
AFOS (Asset Franchise Spread) = ROIC - Cost of Capital
Default criteria:
- > 15% : Wide Moat (Extremely Deep)
- 10%-15% : Narrow Moat+ (Deep)
- 5%-10% : Narrow Moat (Moderate)
- < 5% : Weak or No Moat
ROIC spread and AFOS are the same economic spread lens. They may use different naming conventions, but they should not be counted as two independent cross-validation methods.
2. Inferred Moat Classification
Do not claim an official Morningstar rating unless an official Morningstar source is provided. Otherwise label the result as Morningstar-style inferred moat classification.
| Rating | Meaning | Moat Period | ROIC Characteristic |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wide Moat | Extremely deep moat | 20+ years | ROIC > WACC + 10% |
| Narrow Moat | Moderate moat | 10-20 years | ROIC > WACC + 5-10% |
| No Moat | No moat | < 10 years | ROIC ≈ WACC |
Five Moat Sources (select one or more):
- Intangible Assets (brand, patents, licenses)
- Switching Costs (customer lock-in)
- Network Effects (user/ecosystem stickiness)
- Cost Advantage (economies of scale, process optimization)
- Efficient Scale (market structure barriers)
3. Competitive Advantage Period
Rating Criteria:
- A+ : AFOS > 20%, competitive advantage period > 20 years
- A : AFOS 15-20%, competitive advantage period 15-20 years
- B+ : AFOS 10-15%, competitive advantage period 10-15 years
- B : AFOS 5-10%, competitive advantage period 5-10 years
- C : AFOS < 5%, competitive advantage period < 5 years
4. Moat Trend Assessment
| Trend | Criteria |
|---|---|
| Widening | ROIC rising for 3 consecutive years, or gross margin consistently improving |
| Stable | ROIC maintained at stable high level, competitive landscape stable |
| Narrowing | ROIC declining for 3 consecutive years, new entrant threats increasing, or pricing power weakening |
5. Porter's Five Forces Composite Score
Score each force as risk to the company's moat: 1 = moat-friendly / low risk, 10 = moat-hostile / high risk.
| Five Forces Dimension | Core Question | Score (1-10) |
|---|---|---|
| Threat of New Entrants | How high are barriers to entry? Economies of scale required? | 1=Extremely high barriers, 10=Very easy entry |
| Threat of Substitutes | How easy to find substitutes? Customer willingness to switch? | 1=Difficult to substitute, 10=Easy to substitute |
| Supplier Bargaining Power | Supplier concentration? Difficulty of alternative suppliers? | 1=Suppliers have no power, 10=Suppliers are powerful |
| Buyer Bargaining Power | Buyer concentration? Product differentiation? | 1=Buyers have no power, 10=Buyers are powerful |
| Industry Rivalry | Intensity of competition? Degree of differentiation? | 1=Highly differentiated, 10=Commoditized competition |
Moat Resilience Score = 55 - Five Forces Risk Total Range is 5-50. Higher is better.
- 40-50: Extremely wide moat
- 30-39: Wide moat
- 20-29: Moderate moat
- < 20: Weak moat
6. Buffett Moat Checklist
| Question | Yes=1, No=0 |
|---|---|
| 1. Can you sell at a higher price than competitors without losing customers? | |
| 2. Are customers dependent on this product/service? | |
| 3. Is the competitive advantage strengthening over time? | |
| 4. Can the company maintain its competitive position without excessive maintenance capex? | |
| 5. Do you have pricing power (can raise prices during inflation)? | |
| 6. Will the company be stronger in 10 years than now? |
Score ≥ 4 = Strong Moat
Moat and Margin of Safety Linkage
Use this as a starting threshold, then adjust for cyclicality, leverage, data confidence, and valuation uncertainty.
| Inferred Moat Rating | Starting Minimum Margin of Safety |
|---|---|
| Wide Moat | 20% |
| Narrow Moat | 35% |
| No Moat | 50% or Do Not Recommend |
Inputs
- Target (analysis subject)
- Market
- Industry
- Available data
- User requested depth
- Prior assumptions, if any
Outputs
Moat Quantitative Assessment Report
0. Status
- Usable / Low confidence / Blocked / Not applicable
- Reason if blocked or low confidence: XX
1. ROIC Spread / AFOS Test
- ROIC: XX%
- WACC: XX%
- ROIC Spread: XX% (ROIC - WACC)
- Rating: [Extremely Wide/Wide/Moderate/Weak]
2. Inferred Moat Classification
- Overall Rating: [Wide/Narrow/No] Moat
- Label: [Official Morningstar / Morningstar-style inferred]
- Moat Sources: [Intangibles/Switching Costs/Network Effects/Cost Advantage/Efficient Scale]
- Confidence: [High/Medium/Low]
3. Competitive Advantage Period
- AFOS Value: XX%
- Rating: [A+/A/B+/B/C]
- Competitive Advantage Period: XX years
4. Moat Trend
- Trend: [Widening/Stable/Narrowing]
- Evidence: [List specific metric changes]
5. Porter's Five Forces Composite Score
- Risk Total: XX/50
- Moat Resilience Score: XX/50
- Strongest Moat Source: XX
- Largest Competitive Threat: XX
6. Buffett Checklist
- Total Score: X/6
- Core Moat: [Description]
7. Margin of Safety Requirement
- Starting MOS based on moat rating: XX%
- Adjustments for uncertainty/cyclicality/leverage: XX%
- Final required MOS: XX%
- Does current valuation meet requirement: [Yes/No]
Rules
- Evidence Required: Do not state "has moat" or "strong moat" without supporting metrics, peer evidence, or structural evidence.
- Avoid False Precision: Use score ranges and confidence labels when inputs are estimated or stale.
- Independent Checks: Do not count ROIC spread and AFOS as independent methods; pair spread analysis with peer comparison, source-of-moat evidence, and industry structure.
- Trend Priority: Companies with narrowing moats require higher margin-of-safety thresholds.
- Peer Benchmark Rule: When a credible same-industry benchmark exists, compare against the company with the deepest moat, not automatically the largest company.
- Conservative Assumption: When data is insufficient, default to lower moat confidence or block the rating.
- Auditability: Maintain traceability; evidence must support conclusions.