Critique Skill · 5-Dimension Review

Dimensions

1. Philosophy consistency — Does the artifact pick a direction and stick to it?
2. Visual hierarchy — Can a stranger read it first/second/third without help?
3. Detail execution — Alignment, leading, kerning, image framing, edge cases.
4. Functionality — Does it work for its intended use? Click targets, nav, mobile.
5. Innovation — Does it push past the median? One element that makes people lean in?

Scoring discipline

• Always cite evidence with class names / line numbers.
• Don't average up — score is the worst sustained band.
• 7 = strong, not acceptable.

Output

Single HTML report with:

• Header (artifact name, date, verdict).
• Inline SVG radar chart.
• 5 dimension cards (score + evidence paragraph).
• Keep / Fix / Quick-wins action lists.

Rules

• 5 scores every time.
• Evidence per score — no "feels off".
• Single-file HTML only.
• Radar chart is mandatory.