commercialisation-readiness-check

Help a researcher or team assess whether the idea and team are ready to begin commercialising — from a learning-speed, not perfection, perspective.

SKILL.md

GitHub

Commercialisation Readiness Check

Purpose

Help a researcher or team assess whether the idea and team are ready to begin commercialising — from a learning-speed, not perfection, perspective.

Based on

the owner's published commercialisation guide (owner, 2025). Chapter "Are You Ready to Begin?" (pp. 63-67).

  • Eesley & Roberts (2012) — mission-driven founders are more resilient, build stronger partnerships
  • Christensen (1997) — disruptive innovations rarely look world-changing at the start; they develop through feedback and iteration

Method

  1. Mission test: what change do you want this innovation to create in the world? Mission-driven founders are more resilient and build stronger partnerships under uncertainty.
  2. "Is the idea good enough" test: no idea starts in its final form. Focus on learning velocity, not perfection. Test: does the solution save/reduce/ remove time, cost, or friction, even at a small scale?
  3. Understand the moving target: is your innovation disruptive (creates a new market), sustaining (improves the current one), or incremental (refines a mature system)? Each requires a different pace and funding logic.
  4. Map readiness across four dimensions: technical (prototype scale-up, manufacturability), commercial (customer interaction, value proposition), financial (funding, cash flow), and managerial (roles, governance). These are not prerequisites — they build up along the way.
  5. Identify the balance between over-analysing and moving forward without thought: start with structured investigation, use existing tools (see founder-competence-self-assessment) to test assumptions.
  6. Make the decision: if the idea connects to a genuine problem, the team is ready to learn, and the mission feels real — you're already ready enough to begin. You don't need complete certainty, you need momentum.

Gotchas

  • The "is the idea good enough" test (step 2) is explicitly NOT a proxy for "will the idea succeed" — it only tests learning velocity and small-scale friction reduction. Treating a pass on this test as validation of idea quality contradicts the skill's own point that idea quality is "revealed only by the market test."
  • The four readiness dimensions (technical, commercial, financial, managerial) are stated to NOT be prerequisites — waiting until all four are strong before starting inverts the Method, which says they "build up along the way."
  • Misclassifying the innovation's type in step 3 (disruptive vs. sustaining vs. incremental) sets the wrong funding pace and expectations downstream — e.g. treating an incremental refinement as disruptive invites premature large-scale funding pursuit (see funding-pathway-design).
  • This skill deliberately withholds a go/no-go verdict (see "What this skill does NOT do"). Reading its output as a stop/go decision rather than a structured self-assessment misuses it — the actual criterion ("genuine problem + team ready to learn + mission feels real") is a judgment call the skill only helps structure, not make.

What this skill does NOT do

  • Does not give a final go/no-go recommendation for you — it structures the self-assessment.
  • Does not objectively measure "idea quality" — that's revealed only by the market test.

Continue from here

  • Next in this pack: ../founder-competence-self-assessment/SKILL.md — Work through a structured 10-area / 76-item self-assessment (AFCA) of a founder's or team's readiness for an academic spin-out or research-based startup.
  • Pack's shared guardrails: ../../CLAUDE.md
  • Overview of the full journey: ../commercialisation-journey-roadmap/SKILL.md

References

  • ../../references/case-studies.md — 7 spin-out examples from different industries and regions
  • ../../references/terminology.md — the handbook's glossary
  • ../../references/sources.md — the handbook's own source references
  • ../../CLAUDE.md — the pack's shared guardrails