bmc-innovation-pattern-matching
Identifies and justifies 3-5 compatible business model innovation patterns (from the public 159-pattern innovation library) for a given business context, using the expert's own four-part innovation ta
SKILL.mdspecialisation-packs/business-model-canvas/skills/bmc-innovation-pattern-matching/SKILL.md
GitHubBMC Innovation Pattern Matching
Purpose
Helps find a genuinely distinctive, non-trivial innovation direction for a business model — not a generic "add AI and a subscription model" combination, but a justified selection of 3-5 mutually compatible patterns from the 159-pattern library, placed within the expert's own four-part interpretive framework for WHERE business model innovation typically comes from: finance, operational superiority, the value proposition, or the customer experience.
Anchored in
- The owner's consulting expertise in BMC work, from an April 2026 expert
interview (the owner's research notes,
30_domain_packs/bmc/tools/bmc_innovation_patterns.md,status: accepted,confidence: high). The expert's own quote: "How a business model works as a source of business model innovation — how to make business model innovations using BMC — this requires clear choices in the canvas, followed by the ability to identify innovation patterns." - The public innovation pattern library's machine-readable set of 159
patterns, in four groups / 13 sub-models — see
../../references/bmc-innovation-pattern-library.md. The library's four-part structure (Financial/Operating/Value/Experience Model) is identical to the expert's own taxonomy — these two sources reinforce each other rather than conflict. - The task specification for the recommendation process that came with the
library — see
../../references/bmc-source-material-notes.mdsection 1.
Method
- Gather the business context before browsing patterns. You need at least: the target customer profile (ICP), the solution category, the nature of the market (competitive situation, maturity), and a rough sense of the cost structure (e.g. high fixed capital vs. variable cost). Without these, pattern selection becomes an arbitrary list.
- First identify the innovation direction using the expert's four-part
taxonomy (
../../references/bmc-innovation-pattern-library.mdopening section) — ask: where is THIS business model's distinctive value most likely to come from?- Finance (cost strategy + revenue model combination)
- Operational superiority (key activities + key partners combination)
- Value proposition (value proposition + customer segments relationship)
- Customer experience (channels + customer relationships combination) More than one direction may be relevant, but choose one PRIMARY direction before browsing patterns — this prevents the "pick everything that sounds good" mistake.
- Browse the sub-models of the chosen group in
../../references/bmc-innovation-pattern-library.mdand pick 3-5 patterns that:- are contextually relevant (not just "sound good")
- are not mutually contradictory (e.g. Cost Leadership vs. Premium Pricing in the same model is a contradiction — see step 4)
- are achievable with the described team size/resources
- Check for contradictions explicitly. The library's own rules
(see
../../references/bmc-source-material-notes.md) require avoiding contradictory patterns — e.g. cost-leadership and premium-pricing patterns in the same recommendation are internally contradictory unless the contradiction is explicitly justified (e.g. segmented pricing for different customer groups). - Record for each selected pattern: the
pattern_id(full path, e.g.financial.cost.ai_as_a_service), the pattern name, the sub-model, and a 2-3 sentence justification of WHY this particular pattern fits the given context — not the pattern's generic description as-is. - Record
conflicts_avoided: which obvious but contradictory patterns were deliberately left out, and why. - Record
assumptions: what assumptions were made about the context, if the context the user provided was incomplete on some dimension. - Move the selected patterns onto the canvas — see
../bmc-canvas-clarity-and-iteration/SKILL.mdfor the next step (building a variant based on the selected patterns).
Gotchas
- Step 2 requires committing to ONE primary taxonomy direction before browsing patterns. Browsing the library first and rationalizing a direction afterward is exactly the "pick everything that sounds good" failure mode step 2 exists to prevent.
- Step 4's contradiction check (e.g. cost-leadership vs. premium-pricing) is only a violation when it's unjustified — segmented pricing for different customer groups is a valid exception. Treating the rule as an absolute "never combine these two" will wrongly reject legitimate multi-segment strategies.
- Step 1's four context inputs (ICP, solution category, market nature, cost
structure) are prerequisites, not optional color. Selecting patterns
against an incomplete context without recording it in
assumptions(step- produces a recommendation that looks justified but can't be traced back to what was actually known about the business.
- The library is closed at 159 patterns — per "What this skill does NOT
do," a context that calls for something the library doesn't cover must be
named as an explicit gap, not silently mapped onto the nearest existing
pattern_id. - This skill stops at pattern selection and hands off to
../bmc-canvas-clarity-and-iteration/SKILL.mdto actually build a canvas variant — treating thepattern_idlist plus justifications as a finished recommendation, without that handoff, skips the step where the pattern gets tested against a real canvas.
What this skill does NOT do
- Doesn't choose a pattern for you as a final decision — it produces a justified recommendation of 3-5 patterns, but the final choice of business model is always a human decision.
- Doesn't do financial modeling or profitability calculations for the
chosen pattern — it only identifies and justifies the pattern's fit.
Numerical validation belongs to later, more precise tools (see
bmc_expert_profile.md's own scoping of the BMC's role). See also../bmc-tool-switching-decisions/SKILL.md. - Doesn't replace
../../../../ai-strategy-and-governance/skills/ai-opportunity-portfolio/SKILL.md— this skill is narrower and tied to the pattern library, not a general AI-opportunity-portfolio prioritization tool. - Doesn't invent patterns from scratch — it is limited to the 159-pattern library. If a context calls for a pattern that isn't in the library, name the gap explicitly rather than inventing a new pattern in the library's name.
Continue from here
- Next skill in the same pack:
../bmc-canvas-clarity-and-iteration/SKILL.md— turning the selected patterns into a concrete canvas variant, and the variation logic. - Related skill in the same pack:
../bmc-tool-switching-decisions/SKILL.md— when to move from the BMC to a more precise tool to validate a pattern. - Related skill in another pack:
../../../../ai-strategy-and-governance/skills/ai-opportunity-portfolio/SKILL.md - Related skills in the same pack:
../bmc-tech-level-repositioning/SKILL.md(a repositioning direction not currently in the pattern library, run alongside pattern selection) and../bmc-revenue-quality-scoring/SKILL.md(uses thefinancial.rev.*patterns here for revenue-stream conversion ideas). - This pack's shared guardrails:
../../CLAUDE.md
References
../../references/bmc-innovation-pattern-library.md— the full 159-pattern library, four groups, 13 sub-models../../references/bmc-source-material-notes.md— source material background../../CLAUDE.md— this pack's shared guardrails