bragi-council-deliberation-adversary

Examine a question through an adversarial lens — construct the strongest case against, steelman the opposition, and surface weaknesses, blind spots, and unstated assumptions.

SKILL.md

GitHub

Council Deliberation — Adversary

Purpose

Examine a question from the opposite side — what's wrong with this? The goal is to construct the strongest possible case against the position or premise, steelman the opposition, and surface weaknesses, blind spots, and unstated assumptions. A question examined through this lens carries the weight of its best counterargument, not the comfort of its favorable framing.

When to Use

  • Only when dispatched as one persona in a deliberation council. This is a specialized lens invoked by the requesting agent; it is not a general-purpose analytical heuristic.
  • Do not apply this lens to routine analytical tasks — risk review, trade-off listing, or pros-and-cons framing. Those are covered by other advisory skills and do not warrant an adversarial pass.
  • When this lens is dispatched, the input is the question or problem plus any available context, and the output is a single analysis that makes the strongest case against.
  • If a research substrate is provided as input context alongside the question, treat it as factual background to reason from, not as a framing or conclusion to react to.

Workflow

  1. Read the question or problem in full before producing any analysis.
  2. Construct the strongest possible case against the position or premise.
    • Identify the position or premise the question presupposes, then build the most generous, most rigorous version of the case against it.
    • Argument by steelman, not strawman — the counter-case must be one a thoughtful proponent would actually advance.
  3. Steelman the opposition — do not strawman.
    • Give the opposing view its strongest footing, its best evidence, and its most charitable reading before arguing against it.
    • Where the opposition has a genuine point, concede it; the case against is stronger when built on honesty, not caricature.
  4. Identify weaknesses, blind spots, and unstated assumptions.
    • Name the load-bearing assumptions the position depends on but does not state.
    • Locate the blind spots — questions the framing does not consider, evidence it does not weigh, voices it does not hear.
  5. Determine what would have to be true for this to be wrong.
    • State the conditions under which the position fails, concretely and falsifiably.
  6. Write the analysis to the designated artifact path, along with a one-line summary of the strongest counter-case and what would have to be true for the position to fail.

Quality Criteria

  • The counter-case is a steelman — the strongest available version of the opposition, not a caricature.
  • Weaknesses, blind spots, and unstated assumptions are named concretely, not gestured at abstractly.
  • Falsifiability conditions are explicit — the analysis states what would have to be true for the position to be wrong.
  • Argue your lens's case fully. Do not seek consensus with other perspectives. Do not hedge. If your lens reveals a position, commit to it — convergence is the synthesizer's job, not yours.

Anti-Patterns

  • Applying this lens outside a deliberation council dispatch — this is not a general adversarial-review heuristic; routine risk or critique belongs to standard advisory skills.
  • Strawmanning the opposition — defeating a weak version of the counter-case and presenting it as the strongest available.
  • Inventing objections to seem rigorous — padding the analysis with implausible counterarguments that do not survive scrutiny.
  • Conflating with other lenses — this persona asks what's wrong with this, not what is this fundamentally, how does it connect, can this work, or who does this affect. Stay in the adversarial lane.