multi-agent-pr-review

Runs read-only parallel review of a PR, branch, commit, or diff across bugs, security, tests, maintainability, performance, and UI.

SKILL.md

GitHub

Multi-Agent PR Review

Review a Git-backed change set with bounded read-only reviewers.

Workflow

  1. Resolve the exact base and head, or state that the current working tree is the target.
  2. Read repository instructions and relevant changed files.
  3. If subagent tools are available, dispatch independent read-only reviewers: security, runtime bugs, tests/flakiness, maintainability/architecture, performance, and UI/UX only when frontend files changed.
  4. If subagents are unavailable, run the same categories sequentially.
  5. Merge results with subagent-result-merge.

Default: keep the current selected model; multimodel and quorum are off. The skill name and parallel reviewers do not activate different models or votes. Same-model parallel reviewers remain available with the parent's selected model. Use the task-scoped /multimodel and /quorum commands separately as specified in Explicit Activation.

Cross-Provider Review

When /multimodel or /quorum is active, bind the same source snapshot, reviewed artifacts and acceptance criteria before dispatch. Use the existing worker result contract and a verified launcher; native subagent availability does not establish an external provider route. Host-specific mappings and credentials remain private. Apply agent-squad export and execution limits.

Only /quorum enables the fixed roster and voting decision policy in Worker Quorum: two-reviewer consensus or a three-reviewer quorum. Reviewers draft independently before seeing peers' results. Use distinct observed providers, exclude the change author from votes, and keep unknown routes, abstentions and failed launches out of approvals. An additional review is useful for material disagreement; small changes do not need a model panel. Do not repeat all project checks in every reviewer.

Without /quorum, merge findings without votes or majority thresholds. With /quorum, evaluate records using scripts/worker-evidence.py quorum and verify the actual source and artifact roots. Confirmed critical counterexamples and required failed checks block acceptance regardless of the approval count. The helper validates evidence consistency; it does not authenticate a provider, execute checks, establish isolation or authorize merging. The parent owns reproduction of findings, integration validation and applying changes.

Reviewer Contract

Each reviewer returns:

  • finding
  • severity
  • evidence with file/line
  • confidence
  • suggested minimal fix
  • validation gaps

Rules

  • Do not edit files.
  • Do not report style-only issues unless they hide a real risk.
  • Mark unverified concerns as uncertainty.
  • Use security-router for deep security workflow when security findings are material.