coml-review

Triage an incoming commercial document, route it to the right review skill, run a first-pass red-flag scan, and produce a consolidated verdict.

SKILL.md

GitHub

When to use

Use this as the front door when a contract arrives and you are not sure which review path it needs, or when a bundle of documents (MSA + order form + DPA) needs to be sorted and reviewed together. It classifies, dispatches, and rolls up.

Not for: deep single-type analysis once you know the type — go straight to coml-nda-review, coml-saas-msa-review, or coml-vendor-agreement-review. Setting up the playbook first is coml-cold-start-interview.

Method

  1. Identify document type: NDA, SaaS/MSA, vendor/services, or a proposal/order form. If the bundle mixes types, list each and its dependencies.
  2. Run a first-pass red-flag scan across all documents: uncapped liability, IP shifts, data/privacy terms, auto-renewal, missing exit — anything on the escalation gate.
  3. Route each document to the matching review skill; note which incorporate others by reference so nothing is reviewed in isolation.
  4. Escalation gate: if the red-flag scan hits any gate item, flag it now (coml-escalation-flagger) so counsel starts in parallel with the detailed review.
  5. Consolidate the sub-verdicts into one recommendation and a prioritized issues list.

Example

Bundle: mutual NDA + SaaS MSA + order form. Type map: NDA → coml-nda-review; MSA → coml-saas-msa-review; order form incorporates MSA, review together. Red-flag scan: MSA has uncapped breach liability against you (escalate now). Consolidated verdict: NEGOTIATE — one blocker (liability), two fallback deviations (auto-renew, price cap). Counsel engaged on liability while redlines drafted.

Pitfalls

  • Reviewing an order form without pulling the MSA it incorporates.
  • Sending everything to counsel indiscriminately instead of triaging first — or the reverse, missing a gate item.
  • Producing per-document verdicts with no single recommendation for the decision-maker.
  • Losing track of which document controls when terms conflict across the bundle.

Output format

REVIEW TRIAGE — <counterparty> | docs: <count> | date
Type map:
  - <doc> → <route> (incorporates: <refs>)
Red-flag scan: <gate hits or clean>
Sub-verdicts: <doc → SIGN/NEGOTIATE/REJECT>
Consolidated verdict: <one recommendation>
Priority issues: <ranked list>
Escalated to counsel: <items or none>

Reference

Attorney-escalation gate — route to counsel before agreeing, never decide alone, on: uncapped or one-sided liability, IP assignment or ownership shifts, indemnity you would owe for the vendor's own product, data-breach or privacy obligations, non-standard governing law or mandatory arbitration, anything a business owner cannot reverse, or any deal above your signing authority.

NDA clauses

Clause Standard Fallback Walk-away
Term 2-3 yr (trade secrets survive longer) up to 5 yr perpetual on ordinary CI
Mutuality mutual one-way when we only disclose one-way binding us as recipient
CI definition marked or reasonably identifiable all disclosed "anything discussed", no carve-outs
Carve-outs public / independently developed / rightfully received / compelled narrowed set none
Residuals none narrow, memory-only broad reuse license
Remedies / law mutual injunctive, our or neutral law neutral law, no bond one-sided + liquidated damages

SaaS / MSA clauses

Clause Standard Fallback Walk-away
Liability cap 12 mo fees 24 mo fees uncapped for us / their cap ≤3 mo
Cap carve-outs IP, confidentiality, data breach + willful misconduct breach uncapped against us only
Indemnity mutual IP; vendor covers data breach mutual we indemnify their product
Data customer owns; export on exit customer owns vendor licenses or resells data
Security / SLA SOC 2 + 99.9% + credits 99.5% no SLA, no security terms
Auto-renew opt-in, 30-day notice 60-day notice evergreen, 90-day, uncapped uplift
Price increase CPI or ≤5% ≤7% uncapped at renewal

Vendor / services clauses

Clause Standard Fallback Walk-away
Payment net-30 / net-45 net-15 full prepay, no milestones
IP in deliverables work-for-hire to us perpetual license to us vendor retains
Insurance ≥$1M GL + cyber $500K none
Termination for cause + convenience, 30-day for cause only locked full term, no exit
Audit / compliance annual audit right on cause none

Renewal-notice tracking

Field Capture
Effective / expiry date contract dates
Notice window e.g. 60 days pre-expiry
Notice deadline expiry − window (put on the calendar)
Auto-renew yes/no + renewal term
Reminders 90 / 60 / 30-day pings to the owner