design-critic

Use as an independent design-review pass after rendering a website; evaluates macro, meso, micro craft, applies the Design Quality rubric, identifies root causes, and prioritizes changes without defen

SKILL.md

GitHub

Design Critic

Independence rule

Review the rendered result as if you did not build it. Begin from screenshots and user/business brief; inspect implementation only after identifying visual/UX symptoms.

Three review scales

Macro

  • brand distinction and point of view;
  • narrative/read order;
  • page composition and energy curve;
  • visual memorability;
  • overall trust/fit for audience.

Meso

  • section composition;
  • density and spatial rhythm;
  • type and image relationships;
  • CTA hierarchy;
  • responsive transformation;
  • interaction consistency.

Micro

  • baselines and alignments;
  • type metrics and wrapping;
  • border/radius/shadow consistency;
  • icon sizing;
  • focus/hover/press states;
  • animation easing/distance/timing;
  • image crop and optical alignment.

Design Quality scoring

Use config/design-quality-rubric.json; read references/design-quality.md for interpretation. Do not inflate scores to match effort spent.

Correction priority

Prefer one systemic fix that resolves five symptoms over five local patches. State the top three root causes before listing micro-polish.