CTI Programme Maturity Assessment
Maturity Levels
| Level |
Name |
Description |
| 1 |
Ad-hoc |
No formal CTI function. Reactive, incident-driven. Intelligence is incidental. |
| 2 |
Emerging |
Basic CTI capability. Some collection, limited analysis. Primarily tactical (IOC feeds). |
| 3 |
Defined |
Formal CTI function with documented processes. Strategic, operational, and tactical output. PIRs defined. |
| 4 |
Managed |
Mature CTI programme. Stakeholder-driven, measured effectiveness, feedback loops. Proactive intelligence. |
| 5 |
Optimized |
Intelligence-driven organisation. CTI informs all security decisions. Continuous improvement, advanced analytics, community contribution. |
Assessment Dimensions
1. Collection
| Level |
Indicators |
| 1 |
No systematic collection. Ad-hoc Google searches when incidents occur. |
| 2 |
1-2 threat feeds (usually free). No collection plan. |
| 3 |
Multiple sources across OSINT, commercial feeds, ISACs. Collection plan exists. Source assessment applied. |
| 4 |
Comprehensive collection mapped to PIRs. Source quality tracked. Dark web monitoring. Automated collection pipelines. |
| 5 |
Full-spectrum collection. HUMINT relationships (ISACs, vendors, government). Predictive collection based on emerging threat indicators. |
2. Analysis
| Level |
Indicators |
| 1 |
No analysis. Raw data forwarded to SOC. |
| 2 |
Basic enrichment (VirusTotal lookups). IOC correlation. No structured techniques. |
| 3 |
Structured analysis applied. Threat assessments produced. ATT&CK mapping. Confidence levels used. |
| 4 |
Full SAT toolkit (ACH, red team, horizon scanning). Knowledge cells maintained. Alternative hypotheses routinely considered. |
| 5 |
Advanced analytics. Machine learning augments human analysis. Predictive threat modelling. Community-leading analysis. |
3. Production
| Level |
Indicators |
| 1 |
No intelligence products. Maybe an IOC spreadsheet. |
| 2 |
Ad-hoc alerts and IOC lists. No standard templates. Inconsistent quality. |
| 3 |
Standardised products (flash reports, assessments). TLP applied. Likelihood language used. Quality review process. |
| 4 |
Full product suite tailored to stakeholder needs. Detection rules (SIGMA/YARA/KQL). STIX bundles for sharing. |
| 5 |
Dynamic intelligence products. Real-time dashboards. Automated tactical output. Strategic foresight publications. |
4. Dissemination
| Level |
Indicators |
| 1 |
Intelligence stays within the CTI team. |
| 2 |
IOCs pushed to SIEM/EDR. Some ad-hoc briefings. |
| 3 |
Products reach defined stakeholders. TLP-governed sharing. Regular briefing cadence. |
| 4 |
Tailored delivery per stakeholder. Integration with SOAR/TIP. Feedback collected. ISAC participation. |
| 5 |
Intelligence embedded in all security workflows. Automated dissemination. External sharing (STIX/TAXII). Industry thought leadership. |
5. Management
| Level |
Indicators |
| 1 |
No CTI manager. Analyst works in isolation. |
| 2 |
Informal CTI role. No PIRs. No stakeholder engagement. |
| 3 |
Formal CTI function. PIRs defined and reviewed. Stakeholder register maintained. SOPs documented. |
| 4 |
Programme measured on outcomes. KPIs tracked. Budget justified. Regular programme reviews. |
| 5 |
CTI programme informs security strategy. Board-level reporting. CTI drives investment decisions. |
6. Tooling
| Level |
Indicators |
| 1 |
Email and spreadsheets only. |
| 2 |
Free tools (VirusTotal, MISP community). Manual processes. |
| 3 |
TIP deployed. OSINT tools in use. Some automation. |
| 4 |
Integrated toolchain. API-driven enrichment. SOAR integration. Custom tooling where needed. |
| 5 |
AI-augmented analysis. Full automation of tactical workflows. Custom detection engineering pipeline. |
Self-Assessment Questionnaire
For each dimension, select the level that BEST describes current capability:
## CTI Maturity Self-Assessment
**Date**: YYYY-MM-DD
**Assessed by**: [Name/Role]
| Dimension | Current Level | Target Level | Gap |
|-----------|:---:|:---:|:---:|
| Collection | _ | _ | _ |
| Analysis | _ | _ | _ |
| Production | _ | _ | _ |
| Dissemination | _ | _ | _ |
| Management | _ | _ | _ |
| Tooling | _ | _ | _ |
| **Overall** | **_** | **_** | **_** |
### Key Findings
[What are the biggest gaps?]
### Recommended Actions
1. [Highest-impact improvement]
2. [Second priority]
3. [Third priority]
### Timeline
[Realistic timeline for reaching target maturity]
Improvement Priorities
When improving maturity, prioritise in this order:
- Management (PIRs, stakeholders) — without direction, other improvements are wasted
- Collection — can't analyse what you don't have
- Analysis — transform data into intelligence
- Production — package intelligence effectively
- Dissemination — get intelligence to decision-makers
- Tooling — automate and scale (last, not first)
This order reflects a common mistake: organisations buy tools (Level 6) before establishing processes (Levels 1-5). Tools amplify process — if the process is broken, tools amplify the problem.