design-critique

Get structured design feedback on usability, hierarchy, and consistency. Trigger with "review this design", "critique this mockup", "what do you think of this screen?", or when sharing a screenshot, m

SKILL.md

GitHub

Design Critique

Get structured design feedback across multiple dimensions.

Review the design the user provides. If a file or page is referenced, read or open it. Otherwise, ask the user to describe or share their design.

What I Need From You

  • The design: Screenshot, exported frame, file, URL, or detailed description
  • Context: What is this? Who is it for? What stage (exploration, refinement, final)?
  • Focus (optional): "Focus on mobile" or "Focus on the onboarding flow"

Critique Framework

1. First Impression (2 seconds)

  • What draws the eye first? Is that correct?
  • What's the emotional reaction?
  • Is the purpose immediately clear?

2. Usability

  • Can the user accomplish their goal?
  • Is the navigation intuitive?
  • Are interactive elements obvious?
  • Are there unnecessary steps?

3. Visual Hierarchy

  • Is there a clear reading order?
  • Are the right elements emphasized?
  • Is whitespace used effectively?
  • Is typography creating the right hierarchy?

4. Consistency

  • Does it follow the design system?
  • Are spacing, colors, and typography consistent?
  • Do similar elements behave similarly?

5. Accessibility

  • Color contrast ratios
  • Touch target sizes
  • Text readability
  • Alternative text for images

Keep this a quick check. For a full WCAG audit, use the accessibility-review skill.

How to Give Feedback

  • Be specific: "The CTA competes with the navigation" not "the layout is confusing"
  • Explain why: Connect feedback to design principles or user needs
  • Suggest alternatives: Don't just identify problems, propose solutions
  • Acknowledge what works: Good feedback includes positive observations
  • Match the stage: Early exploration gets different feedback than final polish

Output

## Design Critique: [Design Name]

### Overall Impression

[1-2 sentence first reaction — what works, what's the biggest opportunity]

### Usability

| Finding | Severity                             | Recommendation |
| ------- | ------------------------------------ | -------------- |
| [Issue] | 🔴 Critical / 🟡 Moderate / 🟢 Minor | [Fix]          |

### Visual Hierarchy

- **What draws the eye first**: [Element] — [Is this correct?]
- **Reading flow**: [How does the eye move through the layout?]
- **Emphasis**: [Are the right things emphasized?]

### Consistency

| Element                    | Issue           | Recommendation |
| -------------------------- | --------------- | -------------- |
| [Typography/spacing/color] | [Inconsistency] | [Fix]          |

### Accessibility

- **Color contrast**: [Pass/fail for key text]
- **Touch targets**: [Adequate size?]
- **Text readability**: [Font size, line height]

### What Works Well

- [Positive observation 1]
- [Positive observation 2]

### Priority Recommendations

1. **[Most impactful change]** — [Why and how]
2. **[Second priority]** — [Why and how]
3. **[Third priority]** — [Why and how]

Tips

  1. Share the context — "This is a checkout flow for a B2B SaaS" helps me give relevant feedback.
  2. Specify your stage — Early exploration gets different feedback than final polish.
  3. Ask me to focus — "Just look at the navigation" gives you more depth on one area.