renewal-readiness-brief

Prepares customer renewals: reviews account health, rates six renewal risk categories, spots expansion signals, picks a strategy posture (Expand, Secure, Stabilize then Expand, Defend, Recover), and w

SKILL.md

GitHub

Renewal Readiness Brief

You get a customer success manager ready for a renewal. That means judging how healthy and how risky the account is, spotting room to expand, choosing a strategic stance, and writing a brief that includes a guide for the renewal conversation and how to approach pricing. Account data comes only from the user, from connected tools and sources, or from uploaded documents and connected knowledge sources.

Data you need

The most useful connected tools and sources are:

  • CRM (Salesforce, HubSpot) — ARR, the renewal date and contract terms, who the stakeholders are and how to reach them, and past expansions.
  • Billing (Chargebee, Stripe, or an in-house system) — current pricing, how reliably invoices have been paid, and the data behind any usage-based billing.

If none of these are connected, the user can give you the data directly and everything below works the same.

When to start

Kick off preparation 60–90 days ahead of the renewal date. Begin earlier for strategic accounts; starting later is fine for low-risk contracts that renew automatically. (Multi-year renewals have their own window — see "Adjusting for your renewal motion.")

Preparing the renewal

1. Check account health

Get a current health score using the customer-health-monitor skill. If a recent score is already available, review it; if not, run a new assessment. In a renewal, these health dimensions carry particular weight:

  • Product Engagement — falling usage predicts non-renewal more strongly than anything else.
  • Support — escalations that are still open hand the customer leverage in negotiation.
  • Relationship — a departed champion or executives who have pulled back point to risk.
  • Sentiment — the NPS trend reveals whether the customer is inclined to renew, and to grow the contract.
  • Outcomes — ROI you have on record is the strongest argument for both renewal and expansion.

2. Rate the risk factors

Rate each of the six categories High, Medium, or Low using these indicators:

  • Usage
    • High: usage going down, adoption low relative to licenses, important features untouched
    • Medium: usage steady but not growing, moderate adoption
    • Low: usage rising, high adoption, use cases multiplying
  • Relationship
    • High: the champion is gone, executives have disengaged, the stakeholder map is thin
    • Medium: the champion is holding steady but not widening their reach; little multi-threading
    • Low: strong multi-threading and an engaged executive sponsor
  • Support
    • High: escalations open, heavy ticket volume, CSAT falling
    • Medium: moderate ticket volume, escalations resolved
    • Low: light ticket volume, high CSAT, customers using self-service
  • Commercial
    • High: late payments, the customer has flagged budget constraints, a competitive evaluation is underway
    • Medium: budget flat, no signs of expansion, price sensitivity has come up
    • Low: payments on time, interest in expanding, budget confirmed
  • Value
    • High: no ROI on record, and the customer can't say what value they get
    • Medium: some ROI evidence that isn't quantified, goals only partly met
    • Low: strong ROI on record, goals surpassed, an internal case study exists
  • Market
    • High: the customer is going through M&A, a leadership change, or an industry downturn
    • Medium: some organizational change, budget reviews in progress
    • Low: a stable organization, a growing business, strategic alignment

The overall renewal risk equals the worst single category. One High factor is enough to derail a renewal, no matter how good the other categories look.

3. Look for expansion openings

Check for signals that the customer may be ready to grow the relationship, and make sure you have the evidence each one requires:

Signal Evidence you need What kind of expansion
Usage is nearing or over the license limit Usage data compared with contracted capacity License uplift
Other departments or teams are showing interest A request from the customer, an observation by the CSM Seat expansion
The customer asks for capabilities only offered on a higher tier Feature requests, support tickets Tier upgrade
Use cases are appearing that the original scope never covered Usage patterns, conversations with the customer Product cross-sell
The customer's business is growing (headcount, revenue) Public data, what the customer has told you Organic expansion
Proven ROI makes it easier to justify budget Success plan metrics, QBR data Value-based upsell

4. Choose a strategy posture

Combine the risk rating and the expansion picture to pick a stance:

Risk + expansion picture Posture Where to focus
Low risk, expansion signals present Expand Open with the value delivered, propose a larger scope, and keep ROI as the anchor
Low risk, but nothing signals expansion Secure Reconfirm the value, lock in a multi-year term where it makes sense, keep momentum going
Medium risk, any expansion signals Stabilize then Expand Fix the risk factors first, prove value, and only then bring up expansion
Medium risk, no expansion signals Defend Concentrate on retention, deal with concerns, put together a recovery plan
High risk, regardless of expansion Recover Give risk mitigation your full attention, engage executives, reinforce value

5. Build the conversation guide

Shape the renewal conversation around the chosen posture, in six moves:

  1. Lead with value. Start with concrete outcomes the customer has reached, citing ROI evidence, success plan metrics, or figures from the QBR. Pricing is never the opener.
  2. Recognize the relationship. Mention particular milestones, obstacles you overcame together, and moments that defined the partnership, so it's clear you know this account.
  3. Get ahead of known concerns. Bring up the problems you're aware of before the customer does. It earns trust and keeps you in control of the story.
  4. Make the renewal proposal, phrased to match the posture:
    • Expand: "You've built real results with us, so let's look at where we can take this next..."
    • Secure: "We want to keep building on what's working. This is how the renewal would be set up..."
    • Defend: "We're aware it hasn't all gone smoothly. This is our plan to put it right, and these are the commitments we're making..."
    • Recover: "Your concerns have landed with us. Let's settle what needs to change before renewal is even on the table..."
  5. Be ready for objections. Prepare answers to the objections your risk assessment says are most likely.
  6. Lock in the next step. A renewal conversation must never close without a clear next step that has a date attached.

Prepare for the usual objections like this:

  • Doubts about value ("we aren't getting enough out of it") — have ROI evidence, usage data, and outcome metrics ready ahead of the meeting.
  • Budget pressure ("money is tight, we have to trim spend") — bring an analysis of what switching would cost, the efficiency gains achieved, and a framing that separates essentials from nice-to-haves.
  • Competitor evaluation ("we're looking at other options") — arm yourself with competitive positioning (draw on the competitive-battlecard-builder skill from the sales pack if it's available), an analysis of switching costs, and the value only you provide.
  • Discount request ("we'd need a better price") — prepare a justification based on value, options for multi-year incentives, and options for adjusting scope.
  • Lost champion ("our main contact has moved on") — reach out to the new stakeholders early and rebuild the value story for them.

Renewal brief template

# Renewal brief — [account]

| ARR today | Renews on | Days remaining | Prepared by | As of |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [amount] | [date] | [n] | [CSM] | [date] |

## Health — overall [GREEN / YELLOW / ORANGE / RED]
| Product | Support | Relationship | Commercial | Sentiment | Outcomes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [x/5] | [x/5] | [x/5] | [x/5] | [x/5] | [x/5] |

## Risk — overall [High / Medium / Low]
| Category | H / M / L | Evidence in one line |
|---|---|---|
| Usage | [...] | [...] |
| Relationship | [...] | [...] |
| Support | [...] | [...] |
| Commercial | [...] | [...] |
| Value | [...] | [...] |
| Market | [...] | [...] |

## Room to expand
| Opportunity | Supporting evidence | Estimated value |
|---|---|---|
| [...] | [...] | [...] |
(If nothing qualifies, state: "No sign of expansion readiness has been found so far.")

## Posture: [Expand / Secure / Stabilize then Expand / Defend / Recover]
Why this posture: [reasoning]

## Proof of value
- [a concrete result or metric the customer has reached]
- [another one]
- ...

## Plan for the conversation
- Open with: [a value-first opener written for this account]
- Raise proactively: [each known concern, paired with the response you've prepared]
- Propose: [renewal terms, e.g. flat, expanded, multi-year]
- Expect pushback on: [the two or three likeliest objections, each with its answer]
- Close by asking for: [the specific next step to put forward at the end]

## Internal lineup
- CSM: [name]
- Account executive: [name, when they are part of this renewal]
- Executive sponsor: [name, when executive involvement is needed]
- To do before the customer call: [internal preparation steps]

Adjusting for your renewal motion

  • Contracts that auto-renew: concentrate on detecting risk and finding expansion openings; the renewal happens by itself, but the customer can still churn.
  • Usage-based pricing: swap the fixed-ARR analysis for an analysis of usage trends and projected billing.
  • Multi-year renewals: start 120–180 days out rather than 60–90.
  • Renewals through channels or partners: insert a partner-alignment step between step 4 (strategy posture) and step 5 (conversation guide).
  • High-volume or tech-touch renewals: automate the risk rating in step 2 from health score data, and spend manual effort only on accounts rated High or Medium risk.

Ground rules

  • Never make up what a contract is worth, when it renews, what it costs, or how much it is used. Every commercial figure must trace back to the user, the CRM, or the billing system.
  • Never produce specific discount recommendations or price points. You lay out the approach; the pricing team supplies the numbers.
  • Never assume what the customer's budget or competitive situation is. Ask instead of inferring.
  • Tag where every claim comes from using one of three labels: [Account records], [Renewal playbook], or [CSM judgment].