pre-prd-research

Pre-PRD Research methodology combining Business Analysis, Creative Problem-Solving, Brainstorming, and Innovation Strategy. Use before writing any PRD for problem validation, market research, competit

SKILL.md

GitHub

Applies before any PRD exists: problem validation, market/competitive research, stakeholder interviews, ideation, root cause analysis. Does not apply once the PRD is being written.

Core belief: fall in love with the problem, not the solution.

Four Pillars

Pillar Focus Key Question
Business Analysis Evidence & Requirements What do we know for certain?
Creative Problem-Solving Root Causes & Systems What's really going on?
Brainstorming Possibilities & Ideas What could we do?
Innovation Strategy Value & Positioning Why would anyone care?

Flow

ACTIVITY A: UNDERSTAND (problem analysis, stakeholder map, market research) -> ACTIVITY B: EXPLORE (ideation, root cause hunt) -> ACTIVITY C: DEFINE (strategic synthesis, validation)

Traceability

ID format: [Project]-[Activity]-[Type]-[Number]

  • PROJ-A-INT-001 = Interview finding #1
  • PROJ-B-IDEA-003 = Idea #3
  • PROJ-C-OPP-002 = Opportunity #2

Traceability matrix columns:

Research ID Finding Source PRD Requirement User Story
PROJ-A-INT-001 Users frustrated by X Interview REQ-001 US-001

Details: references/traceability-guide.md

Entry & Exit Criteria

Entry: initial idea/request/problem exists; stakeholders available; time allocated (minimum 2-3 sessions).

Exit (Gate to PRD):

  • Problem validated with multiple stakeholders
  • Root causes identified and verified
  • Market/competitive landscape understood
  • Solution space explored
  • Strategic positioning defined
  • Assumptions explicit and tested
  • Go/No-Go decision justified

ACTIVITY A: UNDERSTAND

5 Whys Analysis

Emit: Stated Problem: [Initial statement]; Why 1..Why 5 each -> [Answer] with Why 5 -> [Root Cause]; Validation Method: [How to verify].

Problem Severity

Rate each dimension 1-10: Frequency, Impact, Reach, Urgency, Strategic. Score = (Frequency x Impact x Reach) + (Urgency x 2) + (Strategic x 3)

Stakeholder Interview Structure

  1. Opening (5 min): Purpose, permission
  2. Context (15 min): Workflow, frustrations, magic wand
  3. Problem Exploration (20 min): Recent occurrence, actions, feelings, workarounds
  4. Impact (10 min): Time/money cost, others affected
  5. Solution Space (10 min): What tried, ideal solution
  6. Closing (5 min): Missing questions, who else to talk to

Questions: references/interview-guide.md

Stakeholder Power/Interest Matrix

Interest Low Interest High
Power High Satisfy Manage Closely
Power Low Monitor Keep Informed

Competitive Analysis

Table columns: Competitor, Target, Features, Pricing, Strengths, Weaknesses. Key questions: Gap in market? Overserved needs? Underserved needs? Emerging trends? Method: references/competitive-analysis.md

Jobs-to-be-Done

When [situation] I want to [progress] So I can [outcome]. Also capture emotional job, social job.

ACTIVITY B: EXPLORE

Brainstorming Techniques

  1. Classic: How Might We... (10 min)
  2. SCAMPER: Substitute, Combine, Adapt, Modify, Put to use, Eliminate, Reverse
  3. Crazy 8s: 8 ideas in 8 minutes
  4. Worst Possible Idea: generate terrible solutions, then reverse
  5. Six Thinking Hats: White(facts), Red(emotion), Black(risks), Yellow(benefits), Green(creative), Blue(process)

Facilitation: references/brainstorming-techniques.md

Idea Capture

Emit per idea: Idea: [Title]; ID: [PROJECT]-B-IDEA-[XXX]; One-Liner: [Explain in one sentence]; User Value: [Why would someone want this?]; Wild Rating: 1-5.

Root Cause Investigation

Systems Map: system boundaries; feedback loops (reinforcing/balancing); leverage points (small changes, big effects); unintended consequences.

Theory of Constraints:

  1. IDENTIFY the constraint
  2. EXPLOIT it (maximize output as-is)
  3. SUBORDINATE everything else
  4. ELEVATE the constraint (increase capacity)
  5. REPEAT (find new constraint)

Insight Clustering

Emit per cluster: Cluster: [Theme Name]; Insights: [List]; Pattern: [Common thread]; Opportunity: [What to do].

ACTIVITY C: DEFINE

Frameworks in depth: references/strategic-frameworks.md

Blue Ocean Strategy

Four Actions Framework — per factor, decide: ELIMINATE, REDUCE, RAISE, CREATE.

Value Proposition Canvas

Customer Profile: Jobs (Functional, Emotional, Social); Pains — [Pain]: Severity (1-10); Gains — [Gain]: Importance (1-10). Value Map: Products & Services; Pain Relievers; Gain Creators.

Opportunity Scoring

Criterion Weight
User Value 30%
Feasibility 25%
Strategic Fit 20%
Time to Value 15%
Risk Level 10%

Score each option (Option A, Option B, ...) per criterion.

Assumption Mapping

Table columns: Assumption, Impact, Certainty, Validation Method. Example row: [Critical] | High | Low | [How to test].

Quick Reference

Mode Trigger Tools Output
Business Analyst Need evidence Interviews, 5 Whys, JTBD Problem statement, stakeholder map
Brainstorming Need ideas SCAMPER, Crazy 8s, Six Hats Idea backlog, opportunities
Problem-Solver Need root causes Systems Map, TOC, TRIZ Root cause analysis
Innovation Strategist Need positioning Blue Ocean, Value Prop Strategic positioning

Common Pitfalls

Pitfall Fix
Solution Bias Write assumptions, try to disprove
Confirmation Seeking Assign devil's advocate
Sampling Bias Cover stakeholder matrix
Analysis Paralysis Time-box, define "good enough"
Idea Attachment Generate 10+ alternatives first

Minimum Viable Research (1 week)

  1. Day 1-2: 3-5 stakeholder interviews
  2. Day 3: Competitive scan (2 hours)
  3. Day 4: 90-minute brainstorm
  4. Day 5: Synthesis and recommendation

Output Location

docs/research/YYYY-MM-DD-[project]/
  research-report.md
  traceability-matrix.md
  interviews/
  analysis/
  ideation/
  opportunities/