docker-architect

Extends a project's docker-compose.yml and Dockerfile after project-bootstrap's base generation — adds the database or messaging service a modeled use case needs, keeps the compose-side image tag cons

SKILL.md

GitHub

Current compose state

!R="${CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR:-.}"; F="$R/docker-compose.yml"; if test ! -d "$R"; then echo "(could not look: project root '$R' is not a readable directory — this is not an answer about docker-compose.yml)"; elif test -f "$F"; then S=$(awk '/^services:[[:space:]]*$/{s=1;next} /^[^[:space:]#]/{s=0} s&&/^ [A-Za-z0-9_.-]+:[[:space:]]*(#.*)?$/{sub(/[[:space:]]*#.*$/,"");print}' "$F"); if test -n "$S"; then echo "$S"; else echo "(docker-compose.yml exists, and the services: block declares nothing)"; fi; else echo "(no docker-compose.yml at project root — run project-bootstrap first)"; fi

Target

$ARGUMENTS

Docker Architect

Keeps docker-compose.yml and Dockerfile in sync with what the project actually needs, after they're born. project-bootstrap writes the base pair — one app service, nothing else — at project creation. Every service added afterward (Postgres, MySQL, a broker) goes through this skill, so there's one owner instead of persistence-architect and test-architect each editing the same YAML their own way.

Entry rule: without docker-compose.yml at the project root, there's nothing to extend. If it's missing, stop and say to run project-bootstrap — this skill never generates the base pair, only grows it.

The ## Current compose state block above answers one of three things, and only the second one arms that rule:

Output Meaning What to do
A list of service names The file exists Proceed
(no docker-compose.yml at project root …) The project root was readable and the file is not there Entry rule applies: stop
(could not look: project root … is not a readable directory …) The root itself couldn't be read — this is not an answer about docker-compose.yml Don't apply the entry rule. Read the file at the path the user gave, or ask for the project root; run /arch-doctor, which reports CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR NOT set
(docker-compose.yml exists but declares no service …) The file is there and malformed or empty Entry rule doesn't apply — the base pair exists. Read the file before editing

How it's invoked

Two paths, both real: /docker-architect by hand — when the user wants a service added or checked, and that is how a pending service recorded by a use case spec gets materialized; and chained by project-bootstrap itself, right after it writes the base pair in its own step 4.10, once per blueprint feature that's already active and needs a container (persistence-jpa → Postgres, observability → the OTLP collector) — see project-bootstrap/SKILL.md step 4.10. A third path: chained by sonarqube-setup for a local sonarqube service when the project has no server of its own; a fourth, by transport-security-setup for the local edge of topology A or the Dockerfile port of topology B. A fifth, by compose-service-installer inside /new-feature-implement, with the use case folder, for every materialize row of the spec's ## Infrastructure — the answer the design run recorded through references/compose-service-decision.md, which this skill owns (@.claude/decisions/0137-pending-compose-service-decided-at-design-materialized-at-implement.md). That's why it carries no disable-model-invocation — a skill the model can't see is a skill a sibling skill can't call.

No longer chained mid-design. persistence-architect, messaging-architect and test-architect used to invoke this skill the moment their spec named a missing service; they now ask whether to add it, record the answer in the partial's ## Compose services, and the implement run adds a materialize row once the code is green. ArchHook.java guard enforces it: this skill is class build, and a build-class call is refused while a design run is open. Why it changed: a design run hand-wrote a schema-registry service with no template, no tag verification and no healthcheck, inside a diff everybody reviewed as a spec (lessons-learned-012.md §§ 12, 13). Record: @.claude/decisions/0058-skill-classes-territory-schema.md.

The guard against firing on an unborn project isn't the frontmatter: it's the entry rule above.

Why this is a skill and not a subagent

Form 1, motivated by the "Ambos" trigger axis: chained by sibling skills mid-procedure, and invocable by hand. The closest rejected form was a subagent — it fails the § 5 counter-test in claude-code-architect-designer's decision matrix on all three points: the service choice is short, its shape fits in templates/, and the diff it produces is a few YAML lines. No context to isolate, no tool to restrict, no model change justified. Full record: @.claude/decisions/0029-docker-architect-skill.md.

Pinned to opus, effort inherited: the one procedural skill with an observed design failure (a broker published to the host and advertised only on the compose network). The pin lasts for the rest of the turn it fires in (@.claude/decisions/0080-procedural-skills-on-sonnet.md).

Boundary with neighboring pieces

Piece Owns Doesn't touch
project-bootstrap Base Dockerfile + docker-compose.yml (app service), once, at generation. Also decides when to call this skill for a feature already active in the blueprint (persistence-jpa, observability) — never writes the service block itself Any service a use case adds later; the shape of any service block, ever
this skill Every service block in docker-compose.yml/Dockerfile — the ones project-bootstrap calls it for at generation, and the ones added later by hand or chained from a UC-driven skill The engine choice itself — that's 20-persistence.md's call, this skill reads it
persistence-architect Engine choice, schema, datasource properties (20-persistence.md) docker-compose.yml, and this skill — records the decision in ## Compose services instead
messaging-architect Broker choice, topic, consumer group (25-messaging.md) docker-compose.yml, and this skill — records the decision in ## Compose services instead
test-architect The pinned image tag inside TestcontainersConfiguration.java (one line, Java side) The compose-side service definition — invokes this skill instead, and both should agree on the same tag

The OTLP signal contract has two owners, one per half, and that is what made lessons-learned-008 possible. project-bootstrap's templates/features/observability/application-observability.yml.example decides which signals the application exports (management.otlp.*); this skill's templates/otel-collector-config.yml.example decides which signals the collector accepts (service.pipelines). The OTLP receiver registers no route for a signal that has no pipeline, so a mismatch is a 404 on every publish cycle, not a startup error. Adding or removing a signal on either side is a change to both files, in the same commit. No rule states this — rules/ is a leaf and cannot name either skill (invariant 1), so this table is where it lives.

Procedure

Project directory. When the caller's one-line context names project: <absolute path>, that directory is the project root, not the session's: read and write every path of this procedure under it, and run every shell command as (cd "<path>" && …). The ## Current compose state injected above reads the session's root, so it does not describe that project: read <path>/docker-compose.yml instead.

  1. Confirm the base pair exists. docker-compose.yml and Dockerfile at the project root. Missing either → stop, name what's missing, point to project-bootstrap.

  2. Find out what's needed.

    • If the target above names a UC-NNN-<slug> folder: read 20-persistence.md for the engine and version, 25-messaging.md for the broker and topic, 22-cache.md for a redis row, 29-ai.md for a postgres row whose image is pgvector/pgvector, 23-search.md for an elasticsearch or opensearch row, and 40-tests.md for whether testcontainers is active and which image tag test-architect already pinned in TestcontainersConfiguration.java (grep -rn "DockerImageName.parse" src/test).
    • If called from project-bootstrap at generation time: the feature already decided it — persistence-jpa means Postgres (the engine application.yml.example's datasource.url already assumes), observability means the OTLP collector. No engine question to ask, and no backend question either: generation stays non-interactive, and project-bootstrap's own final report is what tells the user the collector exports to debug and how to add a UI later. Go straight to step 3.
    • If chained from sonarqube-setup: the service is sonarqube, already decided by its own question (no existing server). No engine question. Go straight to step 3.
    • If chained from transport-security-setup: either the service edge — Caddy, plus its docker/caddy/Caddyfile from templates/Caddyfile.example, already decided by that skill's topology question — or no service at all, only the Dockerfile's EXPOSE line gaining 8443 next to 8080. No engine question. For the edge, go straight to step 3; for the port, edit that one line and go to the report — no service is merged.
    • If invoked manually with no folder: AskUserQuestion — engine (Postgres, MySQL, Kafka, other), version/tag, port, whether it needs an init script. Don't ask what a given spec already answers.

2.5 Observability backend — ask only when it is actually open. Conditions, all three: invoked manually (not chained), otel-collector already in docker-compose.yml, and no backend service there yet. Otherwise skip this step without mentioning it.

AskUserQuestion with three options, and state what each costs:

Answer What gets merged
Jaeger templates/jaeger-service.yml.example. One container, traces only, UI on ${JAEGER_UI_PORT:-16686}. The metrics pipeline stays on debug
Grafana + Tempo + Prometheus templates/grafana-stack-service.yml.example + its three init scripts. Three containers, both signals, UI on ${GRAFANA_PORT:-3000}
Keep debug Nothing merged. Say plainly that this means no UI — the collector dumps to its own stdout — and that the question can be re-asked any time by running this skill again

Don't recommend by guessing the project's future: Jaeger when only traces are asked for, the Grafana stack when the request names metrics or a dashboard. A backend already present in docker-compose.yml is never replaced by this step — removing one is a hand edit the user asks for explicitly.

  1. Check what's already there. The portrait injected at the top of this file is the answer; it lists the keys inside the services: block and nothing else. When it needs to be taken again — the file was edited earlier in the run — take it the same way:

    awk '/^services:[[:space:]]*$/{s=1;next} /^[^[:space:]#]/{s=0} s&&/^  [A-Za-z0-9_.-]+:[[:space:]]*(#.*)?$/{sub(/[[:space:]]*#.*$/,"");print}' docker-compose.yml

    Never grep -A2 "^services:". It reads two lines and stops, so it drops the services declared further down and reports the children of volumes: as services — lessons-learned-012 § 12, where the portrait listed postgres-data as a service and omitted kafka and otel-collector. A service already present gets left alone, and that decision is only as good as this list: a wrong portrait invites this step to recreate what already exists.

  2. Merge the service block. From the matching templates/<engine>-service.yml.example, append under services: — indentation matched to the file's own, never reformatting what's already there. Use the same image tag test-architect pinned, when one exists, so the dev-time container and the integration-test container run identical software. If none is pinned yet, use the tag the engine's template ships with and say so in the report — test-architect's setup mode is what should pick it up from here, not the other way around.

    A tag that no template ships is verified in the registry, never inferred. Writing a service by hand (§ Service catalog's last paragraph) means choosing a tag, and the same discipline invariant 8 applies to a Spring version applies here — a version is not written from memory, and "the serializer resolved 8.3.2, so the image is 8.3.2" is memory with an extra step:

    docker manifest inspect <repository>:<tag> >/dev/null 2>&1 && echo EXISTS || echo NOT_FOUND
curl -fsS "https://hub.docker.com/v2/repositories/<repository>/tags/<tag>/" >/dev/null 2>&1 && echo EXISTS || echo NOT_FOUND

    The first needs a Docker daemon, the second doesn't — run the second when the first can't run. NOT_FOUND from both, or no network at all → don't write the tag: say which tag couldn't be confirmed and let the user supply it. A tag that doesn't exist fails at docker compose up, long after the spec was approved.

    The healthcheck's binary gets the same treatment. curl or wget in a healthcheck is an assumption about the image's base. Confirm it, or omit the healthcheck and say so in the report — a healthcheck that can never pass marks the service unhealthy forever, and every depends_on: service_healthy waiting on it hangs.

    Then give the image a catalog row, in § Service catalog, before reporting. An image used once and never catalogued is an image the next run improvises again, differently.

    Which half leads depends on execution order, and that is why the match isn't only promised here: ArchHook.java compose compares every image: of the compose file with every DockerImageName.parse under src/test and reports a repository whose tags disagree. Run it after this step — java .claude/hooks/ArchHook.java compose — instead of leaving a YAML comment as the only link between the two halves, which is what let a tag drift go unnoticed once (lessons-learned-010.md § 6).

4.5 Database name and the untracked .env — only for a database service (postgres, mysql, or one written by hand from their shape).

  • {{DB_NAME}} in the template is the artifact name with - replaced by _ — the literal application.yml's datasource defaults already carry. From project-bootstrap, it is the artifact it resolved. Invoked by hand, read it from the project: the ${DB_NAME:<literal>} in spring.datasource.url when there is one, else spring.application.name. Never appdb or another fixed literal: two projects from the same blueprint would share a database name, and a host run that reaches the other project's database would log in and run Flyway against its schema (lessons-learned-021.md § 5).

  • .env at the project root holds DB_PASSWORD (and DB_ROOT_PASSWORD for MySQL). The service template reads it with :? and no default — @.claude/rules/secrets.md — and application.yml imports the same file. Create it when it is missing, and append a missing key when it exists, never overwriting a line already there. The value is random, never typed:

    grep -qs '^DB_PASSWORD=' .env || printf 'DB_PASSWORD=%s\n' "$(LC_ALL=C tr -dc 'A-Za-z0-9' </dev/urandom | head -c 24)" >> .env

    Never read .env back with Read and never print it: it is a secret file, and the generated project's permissions.deny refuses the read.

  • .env.example, versioned, with the same keys and empty values, from templates/env.example.example: what someone who clones the project copies to .env. Append a missing key the same way; it holds no value, so it is read and edited normally.

  • .gitignore gets one line, .env, and .dockerignore the same line — the Dockerfile's build stage runs COPY . ., and a secret left in a layer is a secret in the image (@.claude/rules/secrets.md). Append each only when missing.

Redis takes the same .env, .env.example, .gitignore and .dockerignore steps for its one key, REDIS_PASSWORD — generated the same way, never typed. It has no database name.

  1. Wire the app service's environment, only the variables that change because of step 4. For a database that is DB_URL — the JDBC URL at the service's compose hostname and container port, the database ${DB_NAME:-<literal>} — plus DB_USERNAME: ${DB_USERNAME:-<literal>} and DB_PASSWORD: ${DB_PASSWORD:?set DB_PASSWORD in .env}: the names application.yml reads, never SPRING_DATASOURCE_*. Relaxed binding makes the Spring names work too, and that is the problem — two names for one setting, and a reader of application.yml cannot see where the container's value comes from (lessons-learned-021.md § 2). For the OTLP collector that is both endpoint variables, one per signal — OTLP_ENDPOINT=http://otel-collector:4318/v1/traces and OTLP_METRICS_ENDPOINT=http://otel-collector:4318/v1/metrics, matching the two placeholders the observability fragment declares. Wiring only the tracing one leaves metrics pointed at the app container's own localhost, which is silent and wrong. For Redis that is REDIS_HOST: redis, REDIS_PORT: "6379" — the container port, a literal — and REDIS_PASSWORD: ${REDIS_PASSWORD:?set REDIS_PASSWORD in .env}, the names application-cache.yml.example reads, never SPRING_DATA_REDIS_*.

    Every pair is host-first by default and container-first in app. The default in application.yml serves ./mvnw spring-boot:run on the host, so it names localhost and a port the service publishes. The app service's variable names the compose hostname and the container port. A service the application reaches with no published port leaves the host run with nothing to connect to. The collector shipped like that from 0046 until issue #66, and Kafka once shipped with the same mismatch in its advertised listeners. ArchHook.java compose checks both halves of each pair, reading only files. Don't invent datasource properties beyond connectivity — sizing and the rest are @.claude/rules/persistence.md's and persistence-architect's call, not this skill's.

    The backend services from step 2.5 need no variable on the app service: the application talks only to the collector, and the collector reaches the backend through the exporter delta in step 6.

  2. Init script. Write it under docker/init/<service>/ and mount it read-only in the service's volumes:, from the matching templates/<name>-config.<ext>.example when one exists. For a database service this is conditional on step 2 finding one is needed, and skipped entirely when the schema comes from a Flyway migration instead — one source of schema truth, not two. For the OTel collector it isn't conditional: the collector has no built-in default pipeline and refuses to start without templates/otel-collector-config.yml.example mounted, so this step always runs for that service.

    Same for the backends from step 2.5 — Tempo, Prometheus, and Grafana each refuse to start, or start useless, without theirs:

    Service Init script From
    tempo docker/init/tempo/tempo-config.yml templates/tempo-config.yml.example
    prometheus docker/init/prometheus/prometheus-config.yml templates/prometheus-config.yml.example
    grafana docker/init/grafana/datasources.yml templates/grafana-datasources.yml.example
    jaeger — none Jaeger v2 ships a working default

6.5 Apply the collector's exporter delta, and only when step 2.5 merged a backend. Edit docker/init/otel-collector/otel-collector-config.yml — never a template, never a second copy of it — with the exporters: entries and the pipeline exporter lists written in the header of the backend template just used. Two rules: the metrics pipeline keeps debug when the backend is Jaeger (Jaeger stores no metrics), and an exporter is added to exporters: rather than replacing what is there. Then note in the report that the collector needs docker compose up -d --force-recreate otel-collector to pick the file up — a mounted config is read once, at start.

  1. Report and stop. Service added, image tag used (and whether it matches test-architect's pin), how the tag was confirmed — docker manifest inspect, the registry's HTTP API, or a template that already shipped it — whether the healthcheck's binary was confirmed or the healthcheck omitted, files changed, the catalog row added, and — when step 2.5 merged a backend — the UI URL with the variable that moves it (http://localhost:16686, JAEGER_UI_PORT).

    A report that doesn't say how the tag was confirmed is a report that inferred it. Same for the healthcheck: a real run wrote both from inference, and neither was mentioned (lessons-learned-012 § 13).

    End the report with the one command that verifies the result — not optional, and the step a real run skipped — and say what it catches: java .claude/hooks/ArchHook.java compose — every service actually running rather than created, no container from another project holding a host port this one publishes, every published port advertised at an address the host can resolve, and every ${VAR:default} the application points at a compose service holding on both sides: the default reaches a port that service publishes, and app overrides the variable. docker compose up -d exits 0 in all four of those failures. It also prints, as a ⚠️ warning that never blocks, a datasource whose database or user disagrees with the database service it reaches, or that has no password where the service requires one — the login the socket check above cannot see (lessons-learned-021.md § 3). Name the .env keys step 4.5 wrote, never their values.

    The third one is the only check in the system that sees it, so say what it means when it fires: a service that publishes a port to the host is claiming host reachability, and a broker that advertises only its compose-network name breaks that claim on the first host-side client — the healthcheck cannot see it (it runs inside the container, where localhost is the service) and neither can the integration tests (Testcontainers wires its own listeners). It reads the file, so run it even with the stack down — that half answers without a daemon (lessons-learned-013 § 11).

    Don't start the stack here: nothing has been started yet at this point, and a report about containers that do not exist is noise.

    Don't invoke anyone — a sibling skill that chained this one resumes on its own thread.

Service catalog

Engine Template When not
PostgreSQL templates/postgres-service.yml.example Engine chosen in 20-persistence.md isn't Postgres — or, at bootstrap time, when persistence-jpa isn't active in the blueprint
PostgreSQL with pgvector templates/postgres-service.yml.example, its VARIANT — a vector store 29-ai.md declares no vector store. Same postgres service, variables and volume; only the image is pgvector/pgvector. On a project whose postgres already exists, the change is that block's image: line — never a second database service. The extension itself is created by the project's migration, not here
MySQL templates/mysql-service.yml.example Engine chosen in 20-persistence.md isn't MySQL
MongoDB templates/mongo-service.yml.example No aggregate of the document family in 20-persistence.md. Always a single-node replica set with a keyfile — never a standalone server, which refuses the transactions the outbox and idempotency need; the healthcheck initiates the set once. Needs MONGO_PASSWORD in .env (step 4.5). An external MongoDB must be a replica set too
Elasticsearch templates/elasticsearch-service.yml.example 23-search.md names no Elasticsearch projection. Single node, authentication on, HTTP TLS off locally; the tag's major matches the client's. Needs SEARCH_PASSWORD in .env
OpenSearch templates/opensearch-service.yml.example 23-search.md names no OpenSearch projection. Single node, security plugin on, HTTP TLS off locally; the admin password must be strong or the container exits. Needs SEARCH_PASSWORD in .env
Kafka templates/kafka-service.yml.example Broker chosen in 25-messaging.md isn't Kafka, or there is none
Redis (cache) templates/redis-service.yml.example 22-cache.md § 2 chose Caffeine, or the cache is external. No volume and no persistence on purpose — a cache is recomputed from its source — and allkeys-lru under a memory limit, so a full cache evicts instead of refusing writes. Needs REDIS_PASSWORD in .env (step 4.5)
Schema Registry (Confluent) templates/schema-registry-service.yml.example 25-messaging.md kept the JSON default — which is the rule's default, so this is the common case. Only when the partial recorded the Avro/Protobuf upgrade and its trigger. Needs kafka in the file, has no volume on purpose (state lives in the _schemas topic), and its tag has to match the kafka-avro-serializer the POM resolves — verified in the registry, per step 4
OpenTelemetry Collector templates/otel-collector-service.yml.example + init script templates/otel-collector-config.yml.example observability isn't active in the blueprint. No engine choice for the collector itself — one vendor-neutral ingest point, always the same shape. Where it exports to is a real choice, and it's the next two rows
Jaeger templates/jaeger-service.yml.example No otel-collector in the file yet, a backend is already there, or the project wants metrics too — Jaeger stores traces only
Grafana + Tempo + Prometheus templates/grafana-stack-service.yml.example + three init scripts (tempo-config, prometheus-config, grafana-datasources) No otel-collector yet, a backend is already there, or three containers is too much for what the project needs — Jaeger is the one-container answer
SonarQube (community) templates/sonarqube-service.yml.example The project already has an external SonarQube server or SonarCloud — sonarqube-setup asked, and only its None answer chains here. Embedded H2, no database service: local analysis, not a shared server
Caddy (local edge) templates/caddy-edge-service.yml.example + templates/Caddyfile.example at docker/caddy/Caddyfile The project's transport is not topology A, or the developer declined a local edge — transport-security-setup asked. Terminates TLS with its own local CA and forwards over h2c; never writes Strict-Transport-Security, which the application owns (@.claude/rules/transport-security.md § HSTS)
H2 — no service In-memory, runs inside the JVM; nothing to containerize

The collector's default exporter is debug, which writes to its own stdout and is not a dashboard. That default is deliberate — this skill doesn't pick an observability vendor on its own — but it is a starting point, not the end of the road: step 2.5 exists so the gap gets named out loud instead of waiting for someone to notice that "the traces work" and "I can see the traces" are different sentences.

Other engines and brokers (Oracle, RabbitMQ, SQS via LocalStack) follow the same shape as the templates above: image, fixed dev port, named volume for data, healthcheck, environment for user/password/database (or broker-equivalent). Write the block by hand from that shape; don't wait for a template to exist before extending a project that needs one today.

Contract

Class: build — the territory is skill_classes.build's override for this skill in @.claude/schemas/extensions.json: the compose file, the docker/ tree, the Dockerfile, and what a database service needs next to them (step 4.5) — .env, .env.example, and the .env line of .gitignore and .dockerignore. Nothing else. ArchHook.java guard enforces it, and it also makes this skill unreachable from inside a design run — /new-feature and the layer skills record the missing service in the spec, and the user invokes /docker-architect from a prompt of its own afterwards.

Unfiltered Bash: verification drives docker compose (up, ps, logs), docker manifest, curl against health endpoints and java … compose — the subcommands depend on the services being added, so a fixed list trails the skill. Writes stay under guard/guard bash, and a force push is blocked by guard bash (guard.force_push).

Reads docs/use-cases/UC-NNN-<slug>/20-persistence.md, 25-messaging.md, and 40-tests.md when a folder is given; the active blueprint's features: (persistence-jpa, observability) when called from project-bootstrap at generation time; plus docker-compose.yml, Dockerfile, TestcontainersConfiguration.java (image tag only), @.claude/rules/persistence.md, and @.claude/rules/messaging.md.

Writes docker-compose.yml (every service block, including the ones added at generation time for an already-active feature), Dockerfile (build-stage additions and the EXPOSE line, never the base image or base stages project-bootstrap wrote), docker/init/** when an init script is needed, and docker/caddy/Caddyfile for the local edge. No other skill writes a service block into docker-compose.yml — not even project-bootstrap, which only decides when to call this skill — this is the single owner.

Does not choose the database engine (persistence-architect's call via 20-persistence.md) or the broker (messaging-architect's call via 25-messaging.md), pin the Testcontainers image tag inside Java (test-architect's one line in TestcontainersConfiguration.java), or write the base docker-compose.yml/Dockerfile (project-bootstrap, once, at generation). Doesn't write business code, doesn't touch .claude/rules/**.

Похожие навыки: other

limits-colimits

Context management for Claude Code. Hooks maintain state via ledgers and handoffs. MCP execution without context polluti...

Автор: parcadei
3,392

ddttom-allaboutv2-claude-skills-block-collection-and-party

The Block Collection and Block Party are repositories for existing AEM blocks, build tools, code snippets, integration p...

Автор: mattnigh
20

nodnarbnitram-claude-code-extensions-claude-skills-esphome-confi

This skill should be used when the user asks to "create an esphome config", "set up an esp32 device", "configure esphome...

Автор: mattnigh
20