diachronic-claim-typing

Use before literature search and before writing cross-period connection sentences in conceptual history, genealogy, or institutional-history papers, to type claims and audit section selection and over

SKILL.md

GitHub

Diachronic Claim Typing Skill

Purpose

For papers that connect norms, practices, or institutions across time, assign a claim type first, then select sources, design period-sections, and write connecting sentences. If the type outruns the evidence, shrink the claim. This is not a tutorial in writing survey history.

Genealogy here is selective connection of period-sections, not a complete chronicle. What is forbidden is presenting that selection as if it were the whole history.

Trigger Conditions

  • When the research plan involves conceptual history, genealogy, intellectual or institutional history, reception history, or a formation/transformation arc
  • When classics, critical editions, statutes, examination systems, or journal-primary texts likely sit outside paper APIs such as OpenAlex
  • Before writing cross-period connectors ("from…", "adaptation", "continuity", "unique to the present")
  • When cherry-picking, anachronism, or missing transmission evidence has been flagged

Do not invoke for single-period empirical work or cross-sectional surveys that do not claim temporal connection. Use literature-search and claim-evidence-gate instead.

Claim Types

Give each diachronic claim exactly one type. Split compound sentences.

Type What it asserts Evidence required Failure Fallback
T0 existence Source S contains text or record X Locator (edition, transcript ID, catalogue number) plus a verified excerpt in literature/papers/ Invented pages; unread secondary Do not cite
T1 interpretation Inside that text, X can be read as Y T0 plus acknowledgement of alternative readings Unique-meaning lock "a readable cross-section"
T2 institution A practice was a branch of an institution or curriculum Primary statute, textbook, or case One case as nationwide Keep it a case claim
T3 transmission A was translated, imported, or named as B Translation bibliography, introduction primary, or named citation Similarity as causation T3b
T3b juxtaposition Structural similarity of A and B (no causal claim) T0 on both plus a similarity map Juxtaposition without similarity Cut the section or the claim
T4 continuity A method or norm persisted through period P A primary that argues continuity, or primaries at multiple dates Two classical points as "until…" Cross-section only
T5 novelty Conditions at period P differ in kind Survives hostile reduction (quantity/time, degree) The historian already states continuity or a precedent Degree difference, or making a norm/practice contradiction visible

Reception ("has been received as", "use as reception history") is a claim about someone else's interpretive act. Evidence requirements are T3. T1 is text-internal reading only. Without a reception primary, weaken to T1 "readable as".

Prohibition N1 (non-identification)

Not a type. Applies to every type. Do not write that a historical actor held this paper's coined concept. Exception only when that actor explicitly self-identifies.

Workflow

Step 1: Paper type and inventory

Read research-plan.md. Stop if the paper is not diachronic.

If it is, before literature search create docs/<paper-id>/design/sot/diachronic-claim-inventory.md (or docs/design/sot/ in a single-paper repo). Place intended connections with provisional types.

| Section | Claim (one sentence) | Type | Evidence (`papers/` + locator) | Fallback |

If paper-outline.md exists, copy the type ID as one line in the section note (inventory remains source of truth).

Step 2: Selection criteria and counter-lineage

Write one paragraph into the inventory before searching.

  1. Selection criteria (canonicity, institutional embedding, OA primary available, etc.)
  2. Counter-lineage: name the strongest line a reviewer would raise, and why it is out of scope (no straw alternatives)
  3. Sense of "formation": not encyclopedic origin, but identifying a recurrent starting point, etc.

Step 3: Primary layer and search channels

  1. Keep survey histories as Discovery, not citation grounds. Descend to the classics, statutes, or primary articles they rest on.
  2. If a primary is inaccessible, shrink that typed claim or omit the section. Purchase or subscription follows project policy (this skill does not order purchases).
  3. Channels outside paper APIs (classical digital libraries, J-STAGE, CiNii, institutional repositories) are grounded with WebFetch and manual-stubs. v1.0 adds no new APIs.
  4. Then (or in parallel) run literature-search.

Step 4: Connection tests (T3 / T3b / T4 / T5)

  • T3: translation, introduction primary, or named citation? Else T3b.
  • T3b: T0 on both sides plus a similarity map?
  • T4 / T5: does the historian already write continuity or a precedent? Survive hostile reduction (speed = quantity/time, necessity = degree, two points ≠ continuity)? If not, record the fallback and make it a start condition for the chapter.

If literature-gap-analysis novelty is "genealogical connection" and T3 has not passed, change it to juxtaposition/comparison.

Step 5: Pre-draft checklist

  • Load-bearing claims have types
  • T0 stays inside stub excerpts
  • T3/T4/T5 passed or fell back
  • N1: no historical actor = coined concept
  • If the same analysis term (inside, memory, ability) shifts referent across sections, say it is an analytic construct
  • Selection criteria and the strongest counter-lineage are recorded from before the search
  • Teleology style: do fillers such as "thereafter", "thus it developed", "was inherited" hide selection? Does the chapter opening state selectivity?

Then continue to counter-argument-tdd.

Invariants

  • Start the inventory before literature search (no post-hoc criteria)
  • literature-matrix.md is an index; citation grounds are literature/papers/
  • Similarity does not satisfy T3
  • Do not print T0, N1, or other internal codes in docs/chapters/

Out of scope (v1.0)

No survey-history tutorial, no field-specific historiography textbook, no CiNii/J-STAGE search script, no illegal access. Future lint candidates (teleology connectives, "has been received" with no citation, coined concept co-occurring with a historical actor) stay manual.

Outputs

  • docs/<paper-id>/design/sot/diachronic-claim-inventory.md (source of truth; docs/design/sot/ in a single-paper repo)