google-ads-pmax-evaluation

Use when evaluating Google Ads Performance Max campaigns: maturity gate, PMax vs Search comparison, asset performance labels, device/location thresholds.

SKILL.md

GitHub

Google Ads PMax — Evaluation & Optimization

Evaluate PMax campaign readiness, compare to Search, analyze assets and segments.

Maturity Gate (BLOCKING)

Campaign must meet ONE of:

  • Age ≥ 30 days (ideally 60)
  • Total conversions ≥ 50

If neither met → WAIT. Do not optimize. ML has not stabilized. Exception: if campaign is clearly burning money (ROAS < 0.3× target after spend ≥ 3× AOV), recommend pausing.


Data Pull

Query using google_ads_run_gaql:

  1. Campaign performance: id, name, status, start_date, impressions, clicks, ctr, cost, conversions, conv_value. Filter: PERFORMANCE_MAX, LAST_30_DAYS, ENABLED.
  2. Asset group details: campaign id, asset_group id/name/status. Filter: PERFORMANCE_MAX.
  3. Asset performance labels: campaign id, asset_group name, field_type, performance_label, asset type, image URL, youtube video ID. Filter: PERFORMANCE_MAX, asset types IMAGE, YOUTUBE_VIDEO, TEXT. Limit 200.
  4. Device performance: campaign id, device, cost, conversions, conv_value, clicks, impressions. Filter: PERFORMANCE_MAX, LAST_30_DAYS.
  5. Geographic performance: campaign id, geo_target_region, cost, conversions, conv_value. Filter: PERFORMANCE_MAX, LAST_30_DAYS. Sort by cost DESC, limit 200.
  6. PMax vs Search comparison: campaign id/name, channel_type, cost, conversions, conv_value. Filter: PERFORMANCE_MAX and SEARCH, LAST_30_DAYS, ENABLED.
  7. Search term insights (limited for PMax): category_label, clicks, impressions, conversions, cost from campaign_search_term_insight. Filter: PERFORMANCE_MAX, LAST_30_DAYS. Limit 200.

Step 1: PMax vs Search Comparison

Calculate ROAS for both channel types and compare:

PMax ROAS Ratio Assessment Action
< 0.5× Search ROAS Poor Monitor closely, consider pausing if not improving
0.5–0.9× Search ROAS Below par Optimize assets and negatives before any scaling
≥ 0.9× Search ROAS Healthy Proceed with optimization, eligible for scaling
> Search ROAS Outperforming Prioritize scaling

Step 2: Asset Performance Analysis

Google provides performance labels per asset (NOT cost/conversion data per asset):

Label Action
BEST Create variations with similar style/messaging. This is working — make more like it.
GOOD Keep, monitor. No changes needed.
LOW Remove from asset group. Replace with variations of BEST performers.
PENDING / UNSPECIFIED Wait for more data (typically 14+ days).

Group by asset type (images, videos, headlines, descriptions) when reporting.


Step 3: Device & Location Analysis

Device

Device CPA vs Account Action
> 1.5× account CPA Check site/funnel usability on that device first. If no issues → consider -50% bid adjustment or exclusion
> 2× account CPA Strong candidate for exclusion after confirming no technical issues
CVR < 0.5× account CVR Check landing page experience on that device

Location

Location CPA vs Account Action
> 1.5× account CPA Consider excluding
> 2× account CPA Exclude
Spend but 0 conversions Wait for more data OR exclude if spend ≥ 2× AOV

Always check for technical/usability issues before excluding a device or location.


PMax Limitations (do NOT recommend these)

  • No keyword targeting
  • No budget per asset group
  • No placement control
  • No demographic control
  • No channel-level budget control
  • Search term data is aggregated categories only, not individual terms

Next Steps

If campaign is profitable and ready to scale, read the google-ads-pmax-scaling skill for budget scaling, location expansion, and asset expansion rules.

Output must include: maturity status, PMax vs Search comparison, asset label summary (BEST/GOOD/LOW counts), device/location flags, scaling eligibility assessment.