clean-wasted-spend
Use when the user wants to find or cut wasted ad spend: bad search terms, negative keywords, money-losing placements, audiences, devices or locations, fatigued ads still spending, duplicated targeting
SKILL.mdskills/clean-wasted-spend/SKILL.md
GitHubClean wasted spend
Find wasted spend before the next budget review. Find spend with no path back to target, show the evidence, and approve the clean-up.
When to use
- "Where are we wasting money?"
- "Find bad search terms and add negatives."
- "Which placements, audiences or locations aren't converting?"
- "Which ads should we pause?"
- "Clean up the account before the monthly review."
Before you start
- Get the target (CPA or ROAS) and the date range. Default to 30 days; search terms need the full window.
- Ask about exceptions: tests, new launches still learning, brand terms and campaigns that are there for reach.
recall_memorymay know them. - Waste means spend that has no credible path back to target. A test inside its learning window isn't waste. Something with too few conversions to judge isn't waste yet; say it's too early.
Where to look
| Leak | How to find it | Methodology |
|---|---|---|
| Search terms (Google) | google_ads_run_gaql on search_term_view over the full window, sorted by cost, not just the top performers. Classify each term Q1–Q5. |
google-ads-search-analysis |
| Search terms and keywords (Microsoft) | bing_ads_get_performance at keyword level, and bing_ads_list_keywords for bids and quality score. |
Same Q1–Q5 logic |
| Shopping products | Product-level performance. Classify KILL / DOWNGRADE / PROMOTE. | google-ads-shopping |
| Placements, devices, locations | Breakdowns on Meta insights (facebook_get_adaccount_insights with breakdowns) and Google segments. Only judge segments with at least 50 clicks and 5 conversions. |
meta-depth-of-analysis, google-ads-depth-of-analysis |
| Audiences | Ad sets or ad groups spending with poor results; overlapping audiences competing with each other. | meta-performance-analysis |
| Fatigued creative | Ads still spending while hook rate, CTR and conversion rate decay. | analyse-creative |
| Zombie campaigns | Campaigns with sustained spend and no conversions, well past their learning window. | Guardrails skill for the platform |
| TikTok | tiktok_get_basic_report_enhanced at ad group and ad level, and tiktok_get_audience_report for segments. |
tiktok-ads |
Before recommending any pause, read meta-custom-event-interpretation for Meta sales campaigns that optimize for COMPLETE_REGISTRATION. Also never pause the top-converting ad in an ad set (meta-guardrails).
Output
- Total waste: "$6.1K in the last 30 days has no credible path back to target."
- Leaks: a table with the exact query, placement, ad, audience or campaign, its spend and results against target, and the proposed fix.
- Held back: items that look bad but are tests, still learning, or too small to judge.
- Where the savings go: optionally, which proven campaigns could absorb the freed budget (
shift-budget).
Making the change
| Fix | Tool |
|---|---|
| Negative keywords, shared list | google_ads_propose_create_negative_keyword_list (new list, optionally attached to campaigns) or google_ads_propose_update_negative_keyword_list (add or remove keywords, attach or detach campaigns) |
| Negative keywords, one campaign | google_ads_propose_update_campaigns |
| Pause keywords or change match types | google_ads_propose_update_adgroups (needs criterion IDs from GAQL) |
| Exclude a device, or cut a location's bid | google_ads_propose_update_bid_modifiers (a device modifier of 0 excludes it) |
| Pause Google ads, ad groups or campaigns | google_ads_propose_update_ads, google_ads_propose_update_adgroups, google_ads_propose_update_campaigns |
| Pause Meta ads | facebook_propose_update_ads |
| Exclude placements or audiences, or pause Meta ad sets | facebook_propose_update_adsets. Targeting is a full replacement, so send the complete targeting with the change. |
| Pause Meta campaigns | facebook_propose_update_campaigns |
| TikTok (beta) | tiktok_propose_update_ads, tiktok_propose_update_adgroups, tiktok_propose_update_campaigns |
| Microsoft Ads | Read-only through the connector. Give the user the exact negatives and pauses. |
Every change: dry run → show each item with its spend and reason → the user approves in chat (they can approve some and reject others) → mode: "live" with only the approved operation_ids. Never go live without that yes.
Put it on a schedule
Offer a weekly search term analyzer or budget leak agent. With write access and ask_approval, it proposes the negatives and pauses each week for approval (see automate-with-agents).