feedback-write

Model actionable feedback on a placeholder student response against a rubric. Do NOT use with real student data or for grading.

SKILL.md

GitHub

feedback-write

Generates model feedback on a placeholder response evaluated against a rubric. Shows teachers what actionable, growth-oriented feedback looks like. No real student data ever.

Input

{
  "rubric": {"criteria": [{"criterion": "Text evidence", "levels": {"Meets": "Cites 2+ relevant quotes", "Below": "No evidence cited"}}]},
  "placeholder_response": "[Student Name] wrote: The character was sad because of the events.",
  "grade": "7"
}

Output

{
  "tool": "feedback-write",
  "feedback": "You identified the character emotion — nice start! To move from Approaching to Meets, go back to paragraph 3 and find a specific quote that shows WHY the character feels this way. Try starting with: According to the text...",
  "rubric_level_matched": "Approaching",
  "growth_target": "Meets",
  "human_review_required": true
}

Do NOT use this atom for

  • Using real student data (placeholders only)
  • Assigning grades or scores (this models feedback, not grading)
  • Generating rubrics (use rubric-build)

Pipeline note

Follows references/method.md at the Generation step (feedback modeling). Output conforms to references/metadata-schema.md. human_review_required: true — feedback tone and accuracy must be teacher-reviewed.