estimator
Project estimation tool with interactive workflow. Breaks down projects into functional components, calculates cost ranges (optimistic/realistic/pessimistic) with auto-detected risk coefficients. Gene
SKILL.mdskills-web/estimator/SKILL.md
GitHubEstimator — Project Estimation Tool
Overview
Estimator transforms functional requirements into structured, argumented cost estimates through an interactive 4-phase workflow with mandatory checkpoints. Outputs client-ready Markdown documents consumable by Propositor.
Quick Decision Tree
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ What type of estimation? │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
│
┌───────────────────┼───────────────────┐
▼ ▼ ▼
┌───────────────┐ ┌───────────────┐ ┌───────────────┐
│ NEW PROJECT │ │ EVOLUTION │ │ AUDIT/TMA │
│ (dev/refonte)│ │ (features) │ │ (review) │
└───────┬───────┘ └───────┬───────┘ └───────┬───────┘
│ │ │
▼ ▼ ▼
Full workflow Partial lots Specific template
(all 12 lots) (impacted only) (no recette for audit)
Main Workflow (4 Phases)
Phase 1: Qualification
Goal: Understand context and calibrate estimation
- Analyze input (brief, brainstorm output, specs)
- Ask clarification questions (≤3 if brief is clear)
- Auto-detect: project type, granularity, coefficients
📍 Checkpoint 1: Present understanding + detected parameters for validation
→ See workflow-details.md for checkpoint format
Phase 2: Functional Breakdown
Goal: Identify ALL features (explicit AND implicit)
- Extract features from brief
- Identify implicit features (auth, logs, admin...)
- Assign unique IDs (FCT-001, FCT-002...)
- Prioritize: MVP / Should / Could
- Provide AI suggestions
📍 Checkpoint 2: Present feature table + suggestions for validation
Phase 3: Task Evaluation
Goal: Estimate each task with ranges
- Generate task tables per lot
- Calculate: JH_Low × 0.8 | JH_Mid × coeff | JH_High × 1.3
- Apply automatic recette (15% for dev, varies by type)
📍 Checkpoint 3: Present detailed estimation for validation
→ See lots-templates.md for lot structures
Phase 4: Valorization & Synthesis
Goal: Convert JH to budget, document assumptions
- Apply TJM (default 450€)
- Generate budget scenarios (Light/Low/Mid/High)
- Document technical registry (assumptions, risks, stack choices)
📍 Final Checkpoint: Complete document ready for export or Propositor
Granularity Auto-Detection
| Project Size | Granularity | Lots Structure |
|---|---|---|
| < 30 JH | Macro (±30%) | 4 merged lots |
| 30-200 JH | Standard (±20%) | 12 standard lots |
| > 200 JH | Detailed (±10%) | 12 lots + Back/Front sub-modules |
Coefficient Auto-Detection
| Client Type | Specs Clarity | coeff_effort | coeff_risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Known | Clear | 0.85 | 1.05 |
| Known | Partial | 0.90 | 1.10 |
| New | Clear | 0.90 | 1.10 |
| New | Unclear | 0.95 | 1.20 |
→ See coefficients.md for detailed formulas
Tech Stack Preferences
| Domain | Priority 1 | Priority 2 | Fallback |
|---|---|---|---|
| Backend | Symfony 7 | Django | Spring Boot |
| Frontend | React 18 | Vue 3 | Angular |
| Database | PostgreSQL | MySQL | MongoDB |
| Infra | Docker | PaaS | VM |
| Mobile | React Native | Flutter | Native |
Commands Reference
During Session
| Command | Action |
|---|---|
valider |
Confirm checkpoint, proceed to next phase |
ajouter [item] |
Add feature or task |
modifier [ID] |
Edit existing element |
supprimer [ID] |
Remove element |
question [topic] |
Ask clarification before validating |
ajuster-jh [ID] [value] |
Manually adjust JH |
recalculer |
Recalculate after modifications |
détailler [lot] |
Show lot details |
exporter |
Generate final document |
propositor |
Chain to Propositor skill |
Launch Flags
| Flag | Effect | Default |
|---|---|---|
--macro |
Force macro granularity (±30%) | Auto |
--standard |
Force standard granularity (±20%) | ✅ |
--detailed |
Force detailed granularity (±10%) | Auto if >200 JH |
--tjm [amount] |
Set specific TJM | 450€ |
--type [dev/refonte/tma/audit] |
Force project type | Auto-detected |
--coeff [0.6-1.0] |
Override effort coefficient | Auto |
--no-suggestions |
Disable AI suggestions | Enabled |
Output Format
Estimator produces structured Markdown with parseable tags:
<!-- ESTIMATOR_DATA_START -->
| Lot | JH Low | JH Mid | JH High |
|-----|--------|--------|---------|
...
<!-- ESTIMATOR_DATA_END -->
<!-- ESTIMATOR_BUDGET_START -->
| Scenario | JH | Amount HT |
|----------|-----|-----------|
...
<!-- ESTIMATOR_BUDGET_END -->
→ See output-format.md for complete template
Critical Rules
- Mandatory checkpoints — No one-shot generation
- Proactive AI suggestions — Implicit features, risks, alternatives
- Ask when uncertain — Never guess, request clarification
- FCT-xxx traceability — Each task references a feature
- Complete technical registry — Document all assumptions
- User's language — Output in input language
- Parseable tags — For Propositor integration
Synergies
Inputs From
brainstormer→ Synthesis report, decisionscode-promptor→ Technical brief, constraintsresumator→ Meeting notes, requirements
Outputs To
propositor→ Primary — Full estimation for commercial proposalplanificator(future) → JH per lot for detailed planningtracker(future) → Initial estimate as tracking reference
Limitations
This skill does NOT handle:
- Invoicing or accounting
- Contracts or legal aspects
- Estimates without technical scope
- Negotiation (see
negociator) - Detailed planning (see
planificator)
Version History
| Version | Date | Changes |
|---|---|---|
| 1.0.0 | 2025-12-15 | Initial release |
Current: v1.0.0
Owner
- Author: Édouard
- Contact: Via Claude.ai