document-review
Default to this Skill for an unqualified document or Word review and for holistic checks of structure, logic, completeness, terminology, factual support, figures, citations, grammar, formatting, table
SKILL.mdskills/document-review/SKILL.md
GitHubEnglish
Document Review
Read references/productivity-evidence-and-file-safety.md and references/document-review-checklist.md.
Treat an unqualified request such as “Review this document” or “Review this Word document” as this Skill's default. Use word-document-review-basic only when the user explicitly requests a basic, lightweight, read-only check limited to accessible text and headings without editing, tracked changes, comments, complex tables, images, or formatting preservation. Capability gaps do not transfer a generic request to the basic Skill; continue here with a clearly stated reduced scope.
- Confirm the audience, purpose, review depth, source of truth, allowed fact-checking, and whether the user wants findings only or an edited copy.
- Verify the available reader and, for DOCX edits, the ability to preserve structure and render the result. If unavailable, review only accessible text and state formatting limits.
- Review the document as a whole before line edits: structure, argument, missing sections, contradictions, unsupported claims, figures, citations, terminology, grammar, links, tables, captions, and formatting consistency.
- Report issues with location, evidence, impact, and a concrete suggestion. Classify them as required, recommended, or optional. Do not rewrite the whole document by default.
- If edits are explicitly requested, preserve meaning, headings, tables, links, terminology, and traceability; write a new file unless overwrite is explicit.
- Reopen and render the edited artifact when tools support it. Report which textual, structural, link, and visual checks passed or remained unavailable.
Use content-consistency-check when the primary task is reconciling values across multiple artifacts.
Output Contract
- Scope, audience, and capability status
- Required changes
- Recommended changes
- Optional polish
- Edited-file location when authorized
- Validation results and limitations
简体中文
文档审查
读取 references/productivity-evidence-and-file-safety.md 和 references/document-review-checklist.md。
“审查这份文档”或“审查这个 Word 文档”等未限定范围的请求默认由本 Skill 处理。只有用户明确要求基础、轻量、只读、仅检查可访问文字和标题,且不编辑、不处理修订痕迹、批注、复杂表格、图片或格式保留时,才使用 word-document-review-basic。能力工具不足不会把通用请求转给 basic;应继续在本 Skill 内明确降级范围。
- 确认读者、目的、审查深度、权威依据、是否允许事实核验,以及用户只要问题清单还是编辑后副本。
- 确认平台具备文档读取能力;编辑 DOCX 时还需具备结构保留和渲染能力。工具不可用时只审查可访问文本,并声明格式限制。
- 先整体后局部检查结构、论证、缺失内容、矛盾、无依据主张、数字、引用、术语、语法、链接、表格、图注和格式一致性。
- 每个问题给出位置、证据、影响和具体建议,并分为必须修改、建议修改和可选润色;默认不整篇重写。
- 用户明确要求编辑时,保留原意、标题、表格、链接、术语和追踪性;除非明确覆盖,否则写入新文件。
- 工具支持时重新打开并渲染编辑结果,报告文本、结构、链接和视觉检查的通过项与不可用项。
主要任务是核对多个材料间的值时使用 content-consistency-check。
输出契约
- 范围、读者和能力状态
- 必须修改
- 建议修改
- 可选润色
- 获授权时的编辑文件位置
- 验证结果与限制