idea-refine

Refine an existing idea document through guided questioning

SKILL.md

GitHub

Idea Refinement

Take an existing idea document and improve it through critical analysis.

Process

  1. Read docs/idea.md (or the project's main idea document)
  2. Analyze for:
    • Gaps: What's missing? What assumptions are unstated?
    • Contradictions: Do any parts conflict?
    • Vagueness: What needs to be more specific?
    • Missing stakeholders: Who else is affected?
    • Risk: What could go wrong?
    • Scope: Is this too big for an MVP? Too small to be useful?
  3. Present findings to the user
  4. For each gap, ask a targeted question
  5. Update the idea document with the refined understanding

Rules

  • Don't remove the user's original intent
  • Add, don't replace
  • Mark uncertain items clearly
  • Keep the document readable, not bloated