innovation-evaluation

Use when assessing new ideas, technologies, or approaches before committing resources to them. This skill provides a framework for evaluating innovation opportunities systematically, separating genuin

SKILL.md

GitHub

Innovation Evaluation

Overview

This skill defines how to evaluate new ideas, technologies, and approaches objectively. Innovation evaluation prevents wasteful investment in unproven concepts while ensuring genuine breakthroughs are identified and pursued.

When to Use

  • When evaluating a new technology, methodology, or approach
  • When deciding whether to adopt an emerging trend
  • When assessing innovation proposals from teams
  • When considering a technology or tool shift
  • Before investing significant resources in untested approaches
  • Don't use when: Making incremental improvements to existing, proven systems

Core Procedures

Step 1: Define the Innovation

  • What: What exactly is new or different?
  • How it works: Brief explanation of mechanism/approach
  • Origin: Where did this come from? (research, competitor, startup, etc.)
  • Problem solved: What specific problem does this address?
  • Current state: Is this proven, prototype, theoretical, or hype?

Step 2: Evaluate Adoption Readiness

Dimension Question Score (1-5)
Maturity Is the technology/approach mature enough?
Evidence Is there evidence it works? (research, case studies, metrics)
Fit Does it solve a problem we have?
Cost Can we afford to adopt it? (implementation, training, migration)
Risk What happens if it fails? (reversible vs. committed)
Timing Is now the right time?

Adoption Score = Total / 30

  • 24-30: Strong case for adoption
  • 18-23: Worth piloting
  • 12-17: Monitor, not ready yet
  • Below 12: Likely not viable

Step 3: Evaluate Impact

  • Potential Benefit: How much better than current approach?
  • Time to Value: How long until benefits are realized?
  • Sustainability: Will this be valuable long-term or is it a fad?
  • Competitive Impact: Does it give us an advantage or keep us current?

Step 4: Recommend Action

Based on scores and analysis:

  • ADOPT: Mature, high-impact, good fit - begin implementation planning
  • PILOT: Promising but unproven - design small-scale experiment
  • MONITOR: Early but potentially important - add to technology radar
  • PASS: Doesn't justify investment - document rationale

Step 5: Document Decision

INNOVATION EVALUATION
=====================
Innovation: [name and brief description]
Adoption Score: [X/30]
Impact Assessment: [benefit, time to value, sustainability]
Recommendation: [adopt/pilot/monitor/pass]
Rationale: [why this decision]
Review Date: [re-evaluate when, if monitor]

Quality Checklist

  • Innovation clearly defined with problem statement
  • Adoption readiness scored across all dimensions
  • Impact assessed for benefit, time, and sustainability
  • Recommendation supported by scores and analysis
  • Decision documented with rationale
  • Review date set for monitored innovations

Error Handling

  • Error: Pilot reveals innovation doesn't work as promised Response: Document findings, share as knowledge, add "didn't work for reason X" to prevent future retries
  • Error: External factors change evaluation (competitor adopts, technology matures rapidly) Response: Re-evaluate with current information, update scores and recommendation

Cross-Team Integration

Related Skills: source-verification, risk-assessment, competitive-analysis, trend-monitoring Used By: Catalyst, Enhancer, Experimenter, Explorer, Oracle, Innovation leads, Strategos