commodity-gate
Use this before publishing any customer-facing copy (email, post, page, ad). Checks three gates—opinion (can only we say this?), primitive (TAP-owned term used?), founder voice (cafe test)—to keep cop
SKILL.mdskills/shared/commodity-gate/SKILL.md
GitHubCommodity Gate
The premise: AI made the software a commodity. The moat is what only you can say.
If your copy could appear under a competitor's logo with no other change, it's commodity copy. Don't ship it.
When to run
Before these reach the inbox, the page, or the queue:
- LinkedIn / X / Threads posts
- Email outreach (cold or warm)
- Homepage, pricing, comparison pages
- Ad copy
- Video scripts
- Lead magnets
Skip for internal-only work (agent prompts, engineering notes, SQL queries).
The three checks
Pass all three or rewrite.
1. Opinion check
Can a generic CRM, PR platform, or competitor say this without lying?
Pass: "Sending happens after explicit per-message human approval. No batch sends."
Fail: "AI-powered campaign management." (every tool says this)
2. Primitive check
Does the copy use a brand-owned term, or introduce a new one?
Brand-owned primitives should be specific, named, repeatable. Generic terms (pipeline, dashboard, insights, automation) don't count.
3. Founder voice check (cafe test)
Could the founder say this sentence aloud in conversation?
Pass: "Five years of spreadsheets. I thought I had a system."
Fail: "Many professionals struggle with disorganised contact data."
Check:
- Is it specific to a real moment, campaign, or customer? (or generic?)
- Is the subject "I / we" or "this product / users"?
- Would Chris on a quiet Tuesday write this sentence about his own work?
Workflow
- Read the draft
- Score against the three checks: PASS / FAIL per check
- If any FAIL, rewrite that section. Don't ship the original.
- If all three PASS, ship.
Output style
Terse. One line per check: PASS / FAIL + reason.
Example:
Email: cold outreach to Brighton cafe owner
- Opinion check: PASS — no generic CRM could offer 15-minute AI workflow audit
- Primitive check: PASS — "15-minute audit" is brand-owned service
- Voice check: PASS — first-person, specific to Brighton cafe workflow
Verdict: SHIP
Anti-patterns this catches
- Popular LinkedIn carousel templates that "perform" but say nothing brand-specific
- Pricing copy that sounds like every SaaS pricing page
- Cold emails any founder could send
- AI-generated body copy with no names, dates, or numbers
Related
- UK spelling, no em dashes (house style)
- Agents draft, Chris hits send (never auto-send)