narrative-sensemaking

Some questions are "what happened and what did it mean", not "what is the mechanism". Use when an account must be reconstructed rather than measured, when a sequential process has a missing or out-of-

SKILL.md

GitHub

Narrative Sensemaking

Problem shape: the material is an account — an incident write-up, a user journey, a roadmap story, a vendor claim, a postmortem — and the work is to recover its structure: which functions occur in which order, which roles are filled, where the sequence breaks its own grammar, and whether the account is even structurally possible. Paradigmatic/causal analysis is the wrong mode here and produces confident nonsense when forced.

Relevant geniuses

Agent Use when
bruner the question is "what happened and what did it mean?" — decide narrative vs paradigmatic mode explicitly, then analyze the breach of the canonical script that made the event tellable
propp a sequential process (workflow, pipeline, user journey, incident response) needs its invariant functions extracted, its roles abstracted from their current occupants, and its gaps found by grammar rather than by inspection
ibnkhaldun a claim sounds authoritative but may be structurally impossible — filter on structural plausibility before evaluating the source; check whether the reported thing could occur at that scale at all

Invocation

  1. Pick the best-fit agent above. If two or more fit, run tools/genius-invoker.sh route "<problem>" and take the top ranked match.
  2. Load it: tools/genius-invoker.sh invoke <agent> "<problem>", then read agents/genius/<agent>.md in full.
  3. Apply the agent's <workflow> step by step and answer in its <output-format>. State which mode the account is being read in — narrative or paradigmatic — before drawing any conclusion from it.
  4. Typical chain: ibnkhaldun filters out the structurally impossible → propp extracts the function sequence from what survives → bruner reads what the breach meant to the people in it. Run via tools/genius-invoker.sh compose ibnkhaldun propp bruner -- "<problem>".
  5. If no shape above matches, do not force a genius — use a standard team agent (INDEX.md routing rule).

Refuse when

  • A mechanism is available and measurable — a causal question is being smuggled in as a story. Route to causal-audit or failure-forensics.
  • The narrative is the deliverable's purpose rather than its object: this shape analyzes accounts, it does not write persuasive ones.
  • Structural analysis is being used to dismiss a first-hand report that has not been checked against any record — implausible is not the same as false.