evidence-synthesis

Turn a pile of sources into a defensible claim. Use for "what does the literature actually say?", conflicting studies or benchmarks, "is this result trustworthy?", arguments that need claim-evidence-w

SKILL.md

GitHub

Evidence Synthesis

Problem shape: multiple sources (papers, benchmarks, interviews, texts) must be combined into one graded conclusion — and the current draft cherry-picks, skips heterogeneity, or has no explicit warrant connecting evidence to claim.

Relevant geniuses

Agent Use when
cochrane studies must be systematically found, graded, and pooled; publication bias suspected; effect sizes needed, not vote-counting
toulmin an argument needs explicit claim-evidence-warrant structure with qualifiers and rebuttals; standards differ by field
feynman a result is suspiciously clean; a citation is used without the ability to rederive it; integrity audit before publishing
darwin evidence accumulates over a long horizon; the theory needs a difficulty book of its own contradictions; hardest case first
laplace evidence must update a belief quantitatively — priors, likelihoods, calibration
gadamer sources must be interpreted, not just counted — pre-understandings audited, the charitable reading found first
strauss qualitative data (interviews, tickets, reviews) needs open/axial coding until saturation, not anecdote-picking
geertz the evidence is behavior in context — thick description and emic vs etic separation before conclusions

Invocation

  1. Pick the best-fit agent above. If two or more fit, run tools/genius-invoker.sh route "<problem>" and take the top ranked match.
  2. Load it: tools/genius-invoker.sh invoke <agent> "<problem>", then read agents/genius/<agent>.md in full.
  3. Apply the agent's <workflow> step by step and answer in its <output-format>. Every synthesized claim carries its evidence grade and its strongest known counter-evidence (coding-standards §8: no source, no claim).
  4. Typical chain: cochrane grades the corpus → toulmin structures the argument → feynman audits the integrity. Run via tools/genius-invoker.sh compose cochrane toulmin -- "<problem>".
  5. If no shape above matches, use a standard team agent instead.

Refuse when

  • The conclusion is fixed in advance and only supporting sources are wanted.
  • Primary sources are unavailable and only summaries-of-summaries exist — say "I don't know" rather than synthesize hearsay.