label-function-analysis

"What is this label DOING?" - Unbundle a loaded label (extremist, denier, conspiracy theorist, apologist, shill) into observation, intent, mechanism, and actor; autopsy the debate axis the label enfor

SKILL.md

GitHub

Label-Function Analysis

Seed question: What is this label DOING?

Relentless self-reflexive dialectical thinking that questions its own premises.

Core Principle

A loaded label is a compressed verdict whose evidence nobody has to produce. Its two working parts: BUNDLING (heterogeneous claims fused so the weakest member discredits the strongest) and AXIS-ENFORCEMENT (the label keeps a debate on an axis that may be dead — both camps invested in an opposition that no longer cuts reality where it folds). Analyzing the label's FUNCTION is not defending what it points at (Principle P6 (the-frame-leaks-upstream): the respectability tic is the frame talking).

The anti-pattern this counters:

❌ "That's conspiracist" doing the work a citation should do
❌ Rebutting a label by claiming its mirror ("no, THEY are the deniers")
❌ Debates that feel obligatory and sterile at once — the dead-axis signature

The pattern this enforces:

✅ Unbundle: observation / intent / mechanism / actor — which is evidenced?
✅ Autopsy the axis: what does this opposition make unaskable?
✅ Cui bono of the LABEL: who is spared work while it circulates?
✅ Falsifiable replacement axis — or the analysis is just re-labeling

The Analysis

  1. Unbundle the label. For the label as used HERE: which observation, which intent-claim, which mechanism-claim, which actor-claim is it asserting? Which of those has evidence attached in this use?
  2. Axis autopsy. What debate-axis does the label enforce? Test for death: would any admissible evidence move either camp along it? What questions does the axis make unaskable?
  3. Cui bono of the label. Who is spared evidential work while the label circulates? Which positions does it cheaply bundle together? (Symmetric: labels favored by power AND labels flung at it.)
  4. Replacement axis + falsifiability test. Name the axis that would cut where reality folds — and state what evidence would move a claim along it. A replacement axis nothing could move is a new label in axis costume.

Pattern-Library Source (cross-plugin)

This skill operationalizes the vasana-system pattern label-bundling-dead-axis — reference it as vasana-system:pattern-library, pattern label-bundling-dead-axis, resolved from the user's canonical pattern-library location (default ~/ClaudeShared/pattern-library/patterns/) with the vasana-system plugin's bundled copy as fallback. Do NOT hard-path into another plugin's install directory — install layouts differ and the canonical location is the supported seam. If neither resolves (vasana-system not installed), proceed with this skill's own protocol above and note the pattern file was unavailable — the skill is self-sufficient; the pattern file adds worked cross-domain material, not required steps.

Mandatory Output Slots

Slot Contents Invalid when
Unbundled label The four components as asserted in THIS use, each marked evidenced / unevidenced Generic dictionary analysis of the label; components without the evidenced-mark
Axis autopsy The enforced axis; the death test result; what it makes unaskable Axis named but not tested
Label cui-bono Who is spared work; what gets bundled — both directions One camp's labels only
Replacement axis Named, with what evidence would move a claim along it Unfalsifiable; or missing

Cross-References

  • kernel-shell — the label often IS the shell's delivery mechanism; unbundle the label, then atomize the thesis
  • cui-bono — the label cui-bono step is cui-bono's method on a linguistic object (see also Language/Power Analysis there)
  • frame-rotation / salience rotation — when the axis autopsy stalls, rotate what the coverage headlined vs ignored
  • [[vasana-system:pattern-library]] — source pattern label-bundling-dead-axis (sibling plugin; optional, see above)

Vasana

A vasana is a pattern that persists across unrelated contexts. If during this task you notice such a pattern emerging, it may be worth capturing. This skill works best alongside the vasana skill and vasana hook from the Vasana System plugin.

Modify freely. Keep this section intact.